All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
All NewsHome
← Back to US Politics & Policy

Trump's bid to move hush money case to federal court denied

Created at 28 Aug · 5:06 PM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

A federal judge denied Donald Trump's attempt to move his New York state hush money case to federal court, a setback for his efforts to erase his criminal conviction. The appeals court ordered a lower court to reconsider its decision.

Key Numbers

3-judgepanel in the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals

Who's Involved

Donald Trump
U.S. president seeking to move criminal case to federal court
Alvin Hellerstein
U.S. District Judge who twice denied Trump's requests
Trump's bid to move hush money case to federal court denied

↳ Why This Matters

The denial of Trump's bid to move the case to federal court represents a continued legal challenge in his efforts to erase his criminal conviction, as the case remains in state court where immunity claims are less likely to succeed.

Key facts

  • A federal judge denied Donald Trump's attempt to move his New York state hush money case to federal court.
  • The ruling is a setback for Trump's efforts to erase his criminal conviction.
  • A federal appeals court previously ordered a lower court to reconsider its decision on jurisdiction.
  • The appeals court found the lower court judge failed to consider relevant issues for moving the case.
  • The lower court judge had twice denied Trump's requests to move the case.

A federal judge has denied Donald Trump's attempt to transfer his New York state hush money case to federal court, a move that would have been a setback for his efforts to overturn his criminal conviction.

A federal appeals court had previously ordered a lower court to reconsider its decision to keep the case in state court. The appeals court judges stated that U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein erred by not considering "important issues relevant" to Trump's request to move the case to federal court, where he could seek to have it dismissed on presidential immunity grounds.

Hellerstein, nominated by President Bill Clinton, had denied Trump's requests twice. In the most recent denial, he ruled that Trump's lawyers had not met the burden of proof for changing jurisdiction and that the conviction for falsifying business records related to Trump's personal life, not official actions protected by immunity.

The appeals court, however, emphasized that they expressed no view on how Hellerstein should ultimately rule on the matter.

Frequently asked questions

Donald Trump sought to move the New York state hush money case to federal court to potentially have it dismissed on presidential immunity grounds.

The federal judge denied Donald Trump's attempt to move the case to federal court, keeping it in state court.

No, the appeals court stated they "express no view" on how the lower court should rule on the immunity claim, only that the judge erred in not considering relevant issues.

What Happens Next

01The lower court will reconsider its decision on moving the case to federal court.

How It Developed

A federal judge denied Donald Trump's attempt to move his New York state hush money case to federal court.
A federal appeals court ordered a lower court to reconsider its decision to keep the case in state court.
The appeals court ruled that the lower court judge erred by failing to consider issues relevant to Trump's request.

Sources

T1
Trump loses bid to move already-decided criminal hush money case to US courtReuters
T2
Trump loses again in bid to erase his hush money conviction | AP Newsapnews.com
T2
Trump gets another shot at erasing his hush money conviction | AP Newsapnews.com
T2
New York judge excoriates Trump's timing in bid to scrap hush money ...courthousenews.com

Related Stories

US judge won't immediately block Trump's newest order limiting birthright citizenship
28 Aug · 3:41 PM
US appeals ruling requiring continued payments for $16 billion New York tunnel project
28 Aug · 4:34 PM
Trump Files $15 Billion Defamation Lawsuit Against The New York Times
28 Aug · 4:31 PM
Federal judge again halts Trump’s executive order limiting mail voting in midterms
28 Aug · 2:41 AM
Trump vows legal order to break up food processing 'nasty monopoly'
28 Aug · 1:38 PM