Key facts
- US District Judge Amit Mehta dismissed antitrust lawsuits against Google filed by Chegg and Penske Media.
- The lawsuits alleged Google's AI search features, like AI overviews, illegally harvested content and reduced traffic to publishers' sites.
- Judge Mehta ruled that Google's conduct does not violate antitrust law, stating that publishers' expectation of search traffic is not a formal agreement.
- Mehta acknowledged the economic harm to publishers but stated that not all economic harm is the product of an illegal act.
- The judge noted that antitrust laws cannot be applied in place of legislative action for perceived unfairness.
A US federal judge has dismissed antitrust lawsuits filed by Chegg and Penske Media against Google, ruling that the tech giant's use of content for its AI search features does not violate antitrust law. The publishers had accused Google of illegally scraping their content to train AI models like Gemini, which they claimed led to a decrease in website traffic.
US District Judge Amit Mehta stated that while publishers may have an "expectation" of receiving search traffic from Google in exchange for making their content available for free, this expectation does not constitute a legally binding agreement. Therefore, he concluded that Google's conduct did not fall under antitrust violations.
Mehta acknowledged the potential harm to publishers and journalists whose content is used without compensation, noting that "the court does not treat Plaintiffs’ alleged harms lightly." However, he emphasized that antitrust laws are written and cannot be retroactively applied to address perceived unfairness or economic harm resulting from innovation.
The judge, who also presided over the DOJ's search antitrust case against Google, indicated that absent new legislation, publishers face an uphill battle in US courts. The European Commission is reportedly considering similar questions, and the UK has mandated Google to offer an opt-out for sites wishing to remain in organic search results.
