Key facts
- CNN, Politico, and MS Now reporters were denied White House access on Thursday.
- A federal judge ordered the Trump administration to restore reporters' press credentials.
- The White House's refusal to admit reporters came hours after the judge's order.
- The judge found the administration's decision to revoke credentials likely violated due-process rights.
- President Trump accused the outlets of publishing 'fake news' and banned access.
Journalists from CNN, Politico, and MS Now were denied entry to the White House on Thursday, September 24, despite a federal judge ordering the Trump administration to restore their press credentials. The three news organizations subsequently asked the court for an emergency hearing, arguing that the administration had not complied with the order.
President Donald Trump had announced the ban on September 18, accusing the outlets of repeatedly publishing what he described as "fake news." The following day, reporters from the three outlets reported their White House credentials had been deactivated.
US District Judge Timothy Kelly issued a temporary restraining order early Thursday morning in the lawsuit brought by CNN, MS Now, and Politico. The order directs the administration to "immediately return, reinstate, and restore" the journalists’ White House hard-pass credentials for 14 days. Kelly stated the administration’s decision to revoke the credentials likely violated the journalists’ constitutional due-process rights, focusing on the absence of adequate notice and an opportunity for the affected journalists to challenge the decision before their access was revoked. The ruling does not represent a final decision on the broader First Amendment dispute but temporarily restores access while the case proceeds.
The White House defended its decision by arguing that access to the White House is a privilege, not a constitutional right. The three outlets filed a federal lawsuit on September 21, arguing the ban violated the First Amendment's protections for freedom of the press and the Fifth Amendment's guarantee of due process, partly on the claim that the government retaliated against them due to their reporting. For a second time in a week, the White House had unilaterally removed CNN from its assignment as the primary television pool representative covering Donald Trump, excluding the network from pool duty aboard Air Force One on Saturday. On Sunday, the White House published a pool assignment list that listed CNN as in-town pooler for Thursday’s activities, with Real America’s Voice serving as secondary pooler. However, on Wednesday night, the White House abruptly removed CNN from pool duty for the following day, leaving Real America’s Voice as the only pooler.
