Key facts
- Zelensky said Ukraine still needs clarity on who the collective would consist of and how it would defend Ukraine.
- Zelensky said guarantees must be on paper, not just words, and last at least decades.
- Zelensky said NATO membership remains Ukraine's preferred guarantee and would be cheaper for everyone.
- Without NATO membership, Zelensky said Ukraine would need an army of around one million personnel.
- NATO allies reaffirmed Ukraine's membership path at the 2024 Washington summit, but no invitation consensus exists.
President Volodymyr Zelensky said on November 21 that Ukraine has not seen written commitments setting out how proposed NATO-style security guarantees would work, speaking to reporters.
The remarks followed U.S. envoy Jared Kushner saying in Berlin on November 19 that Washington was open to providing Ukraine with guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5 collective defense provision, during talks with European leaders. Responding to a question from the Kyiv Independent, Zelensky said Ukraine still needed clarity on what the proposed commitments would entail. "Article 5 is collective defense," Zelensky said. "What remains unclear for Ukraine is who exactly this collective would consist of, how it would defend us, and whether it would be prepared to repel the aggressor."
Article 5 requires all members to render immediate aid to any partner that comes under attack. Zelensky said the answers "must not simply be words" and "must be on paper," adding: "So far, I have not seen such commitments on paper."
Zelensky also said any guarantees must remain effective beyond U.S. President Donald Trump's time in office. "We need guarantees not for two years, but preferably forever. At least for decades," he said.
He reiterated that NATO membership remained Ukraine's preferred security guarantee, arguing that joining the alliance would both strengthen NATO and reduce the cost of Ukraine's defense. Without membership, he said, Ukraine would need to maintain an army of around one million personnel, alongside sufficient aircraft, artillery, missiles and air defense capabilities. "All of this will certainly exist if Ukraine becomes a NATO member, but it will definitely be cheaper for everyone," Zelensky said.
