All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
All NewsHome
← Back to US Politics & Policy

Taiwan election commission rejects caning referendum proposal

Created at 28 Aug · 11:17 AM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

Taiwan's Central Election Commission rejected a parliamentary proposal for a referendum on legalizing caning for serious crimes, citing international human rights commitments. The opposition Kuomintang party expressed regret over the decision.

Who's Involved

Central Election Commission
Taiwanese body that rejected the referendum proposal
Michael You
Chairman of Taiwan's Central Election Commission
Hung Meng-kai
Lawmaker who proposed the caning referendum
Kuomintang
Taiwan's largest opposition party, which proposed the referendum
Amnesty International
Human rights group that criticized the proposal

↳ Why This Matters

The rejection of the caning referendum proposal highlights Taiwan's commitment to international human rights standards, even as it navigates public sentiment regarding crime and punishment. It underscores the tension between democratic processes like referendums and established legal and human rights frameworks.

Key facts

  • Taiwan's Central Election Commission rejected a referendum proposal to legalize caning for serious crimes.
  • The commission stated the proposal violates international human rights commitments.
  • Parliament had previously passed the proposal, which was opposed by the ruling party.
  • The opposition Kuomintang party lawmaker who proposed the referendum expressed regret.

Taiwan's Central Election Commission on Friday rejected a proposal passed by parliament to hold a referendum on legalizing caning for serious crimes such as sexual assault and fraud. The commission stated that the punishment would contravene the island's international human rights commitments.

Central Election Commission Chairman Michael You explained that Taiwan has already incorporated international human rights commitments into its laws, and that caning is widely considered a cruel and inhuman punishment that violates human dignity. The proposal for the referendum was put forward by Hung Meng-kai, a lawmaker from the opposition Kuomintang party, who expressed regret over the commission's decision. He argued that the public should have had the opportunity to vote on the matter and questioned whether the decision protected criminals rather than victims.

The proposal had also faced criticism from Taiwan's National Human Rights Commission and international organizations like Amnesty International. Taiwan, a full democracy with extensive legal protections for human rights, still retains the death penalty, though it is rarely used. Referendums are held periodically in Taiwan, typically after citizens gather sufficient signatures for specific proposals. In a previous instance, a referendum to reopen Taiwan's last nuclear plant failed to meet the required voter turnout threshold.

Frequently asked questions

The commission rejected the proposal because it would violate Taiwan's international human rights commitments, deeming caning a cruel and inhuman punishment.

The referendum was proposed by Hung Meng-kai, a lawmaker from Taiwan's largest opposition party, the Kuomintang.

Taiwan is a full democracy with wide-ranging legal protections for human rights and has enacted international commitments on human rights into law.

What Happens Next

01The Cabinet has three months to send relevant legislation to parliament for approval if referendums pass.

How It Developed

Taiwan's parliament voted to hold a referendum on legalizing caning for serious crimes.
The Central Election Commission rejected the referendum proposal.
The commission cited international human rights commitments as the reason for rejection.
A lawmaker from the opposition Kuomintang party expressed regret over the decision.

Sources

T1
Taiwan election commission rejects caning referendum proposalReuters

Related Stories

China court gives ex-Hubei party chief suspended death sentence for bribery
28 Aug · 9:51 AM
UN rights office condemns Trump administration's designation of Palestine Action as terrorist group
27 Aug · 10:00 PM
Eswatini receives two more third-country deportees from US
27 Aug · 6:59 PM
Presidential office asks chief justice for new Supreme Court nominee
28 Aug · 5:36 AM
Nvidia to launch employee-funded U.S. political action committee
27 Aug · 3:46 PM