Key facts
- Senior Liberal Democrat MPs have privately criticized party leader Sir Ed Davey's defense of the pension triple lock.
- Some Lib Dem MPs believe the majority of the parliamentary party disagrees with Davey's stance on adjusting the triple lock.
- MP Tom Gordon described Davey's reasoning for keeping the triple lock as "nonsense" and "gaslighting."
- MP Vikki Slade suggested most millennials do not expect to receive a state pension.
- Labour's plan, proposed by Andy Burnham, aims to raise £15bn a year by removing the automatic link with average earnings from 2030, while ensuring the state pension rises with inflation or 2.5%, whichever is higher.
Liberal Democrat MPs are privately criticizing their party leader, Sir Ed Davey, over his defense of the pension triple lock, with some suggesting that the majority of the parliamentary party disagrees with his position. The controversy stems from Davey's response to proposals aimed at adjusting the policy, which guarantees the state pension increases annually based on inflation, wage growth, or 2.5%, whichever is highest.
Multiple Lib Dems have voiced criticism, both publicly and privately. One MP told the BBC that most of the parliamentary party would not support opposing proposed changes to the triple lock. Tom Gordon, the MP for Harrogate & Knaresborough, described Davey's reasoning for maintaining the triple lock as "nonsense" and "gaslighting an entire generation into believing it's for our benefit." He argued that telling millennials the triple lock will help them in 30 years is "at best for the birds, and at worst downright insulting," given current economic challenges.
Vikki Slade, the MP for Mid-Dorset and North Poole, commented that most millennials do not anticipate having a state pension when they retire, suggesting the policy is not being considered with their future in mind. She expressed pride in the triple lock when it was introduced by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition in 2010 but emphasized the need to plan for the future rather than venerate the past.
A Liberal Democrat spokesperson acknowledged the triple lock's controversial nature and its past benefits but stated its work is not yet done. The spokesperson added that Labour's plan would push too many current workers into poverty upon retirement and urged Andy Burnham to find a lasting consensus on social care with a sustainable funding model.
Some senior Lib Dems reportedly believe Sir Ed Davey's leadership position has been vulnerable, though they stressed no immediate challenge is imminent. The internal dissent highlights a struggle within the party to articulate its values effectively, particularly in response to Labour's policy proposals.