Key facts
- CRMLS filed a federal lawsuit seeking to block Compass's planned antitrust suit.
- CRMLS argues Compass wants to withhold listings for competitive gain while using MLS data.
- Compass plans to sue CRMLS over fines for publicly marketing office exclusive listings.
- CRMLS maintains its cooperation rules promote a fair and transparent marketplace.
- The dispute centers on whether properties publicly marketed but not entered into the MLS should be accessible to all brokers.
California Regional Multiple Listing Service (CRMLS) has filed a federal lawsuit in New York seeking to affirm the legality of its listing cooperation rules and block an anticipated antitrust lawsuit from Compass International Holdings. CRMLS alleges that Compass has sought to weaken cooperation requirements to allow the brokerage to market some listings exclusively while withholding them from the MLS, thereby gaining a competitive advantage.
In its complaint, CRMLS argues that Compass wants to "free-ride" on the comprehensive listing contributions of other brokerages while hoarding its own inventory for exclusive financial benefit. The dispute specifically concerns how publicly marketed listings not entered into the MLS are treated. CRMLS believes that once a property is advertised publicly, cooperating brokers and their clients should have equal access to that information.
Compass CEO Robert Reffkin had previously announced plans to sue CRMLS, alleging that the MLS's rules, which he claims changed in 2019, unfairly restrict marketing practices. CRMLS CEO Art Carter countered that the MLS's rules are designed to promote transparency, competition, and cooperation, ultimately serving both consumers and brokers. CRMLS is seeking a declaratory judgment that its rules do not violate antitrust laws and an injunction to prevent Compass from pursuing such claims. CRMLS also plans to establish an MLS Cooperation Legal Defense Fund to support its stance.
