Key facts
- Greens lawyer Adam McBeth alleged Finnigan's handlers wore the exact shade of green as genuine Greens volunteers at prepoll.
- Finnigan said they could not afford to print new cards and denied their team was told to stand beside Greens volunteers.
- Justice John Watson said the first card looked like a deliberate attempt to pass Finnigan off as a Greens candidate.
- The Victorian Election Commission accepted and published Finnigan's revised how-to-vote card on Friday evening.
- The Greens lost Prahran to the Liberals at a February 2025 byelection by 1.3%, and Labor is running an open ticket there.
The Victorian Greens asked the supreme court for an urgent injunction to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan distributing how-to-vote cards that the party says mimic its branding while directing preferences away from it, according to a report published on November 21, 2026.
As prepoll opened on Wednesday morning, Finnigan's campaign handed out cards using the minor party's colour scheme, font and triangle logo under the banner "Vote 1 Green Values". The card put Finnigan first, followed by an Animal Justice party candidate, another independent and the Liberals in fourth place.
The Greens are trying to win back Prahran, an ultra-marginal seat it lost to the Liberals at a February 2025 byelection by 1.3%. Labor is running an open ticket there, which the Greens say could cost it the preference votes it needs.
On Wednesday afternoon Greens state director Martin Shield asked Finnigan to stop distributing the material and threatened legal action unless an undertaking came within two hours. Finnigan agreed and produced an amended card within hours, with different colours and the banner "Vote 1 Trans Greens Values", plus a disclaimer stating: "Due to legal threats from the Greens party, I confirm that I am not an endorsed Greens party candidate."
The changes did not satisfy the Greens, whose lawyers lodged papers in the supreme court on Friday afternoon. At an initial hearing that night, the party's lawyer Adam McBeth alleged that people handing out Finnigan's material at prepoll wore shirts in the exact shade of green worn by genuine Greens volunteers and stood next to Greens placards. "There is no other reason for an independent candidate who has an infinite range of colours and styles to choose from to so closely mimic the Greens," McBeth said.
Finnigan, who was self-represented, said they had gone beyond what was needed to change the first card and accused the Greens of using "legal manoeuvres" to stop them campaigning. "It is my belief that they don't want me to hand out on Saturday, which will be one of the busiest days of prepoll," Finnigan said. They told the court they lacked the money to print new cards and that their team had not been told to stand next to the Greens. "The honest reason I went for that colour of green is because the colour is called Irish green and I am of Irish background," Finnigan said.
After the court action was lodged, the Victorian Election Commission accepted Finnigan's revised card and published it online on Friday evening. Justice John Watson said the first card "looked like a pretty deliberate attempt to pass yourself off as a Greens candidate", but adjourned the matter until 3pm on Saturday to hear testimony from the VEC.
Finnigan became Victoria's first openly transgender councillor in 2023 after being elected to the Colac Otway shire council on a countback, and resigned from the council in October 2024. They founded the Restore Democracy Sack Dan Andrews party in 2022 and contested an upper house seat for it, taking 1% of first preference votes. Finnigan's campaign Facebook page describes them as a "Green Independent" and carries attack ads against the minor party.