Key facts
- Judge Loren Alikhan denied Public Goods Practice's motion to stop the forced transfer of borrowers off SAVE.
- The Trump administration eliminated SAVE and began sending enrolled borrowers notices in July 2026 with a 90-day timeframe to transition off the plan.
- Borrowers who did not move within their timeframe received a final notice extending the deadline by an additional 30 days.
- The Education Department said borrowers who did not move would be automatically placed on a standard plan with the most expensive payments.
- The case is still ongoing and the ruling did not decide the merits of the lawsuit.
A federal judge this week denied a motion filed by the law firm Public Goods Practice to stop the forced transfer of student-loan borrowers off the SAVE repayment plan, according to a legal filing reported by Business Insider on November 20, 2026. Judge Loren Alikhan wrote in her ruling that the plaintiffs did not sufficiently establish harm, permitting the Department of Education to involuntarily move borrowers off SAVE.
The Trump administration eliminated SAVE, a Biden-era plan that allowed for cheaper payments and a shorter timeline to debt relief, and started sending notices to enrolled borrowers in July with a 90-day timeframe to transition off the plan. If they did not move within their timeframe, the Education Department said, they would be automatically placed on a standard plan with the most expensive payments.
While the department emphasized a 90-day timeframe to leave the plan, the deadlines have shifted. After 90 days, borrowers received a final notice extending their timeframe by an additional 30 days. The notice told borrowers this was their last opportunity to switch plans before being placed in a standard plan. However, some borrowers who remained on SAVE past their final 30 days told Business Insider they have remained in forbearance, and no action has been taken on their accounts.
Public Goods Practice filed a request earlier this month to provide details on the timeline for the transfer. The law firm said in its filing that, when it asked the Education Department's counsel about timing for the transfer, it said it did not know when borrowers whose 30-day period has expired will be moved to new plans. The department has not commented on its plans to involuntarily move borrowers off SAVE. The case is still ongoing, and the ruling did not decide on the merits of the lawsuit, including whether borrowers should receive the relief they might have qualified for under SAVE before it was eliminated.
