Key facts
- Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward asked the Ninth Circuit to dismiss the case and vacate Judge Sharon Gleason's November 1 ruling.
- Prosecutors said ballots for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. were already mixed with other votes, preventing a determination of voter intent.
- Gleason ruled prosecutors lacked standing because their proposed investigation offered no workable remedy.
- Alaska officials opposed the federal challenge, arguing the department lacked authority to interfere with certification.
- The League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause asked the Ninth Circuit to affirm the dismissal and consider sanctions.
The US Justice Department asked the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on November 19, 2026, to dismiss as moot its lawsuit challenging Democrat Mary Peltola's victory in Alaska's US Senate race, and to vacate an earlier ruling against the department.
In the filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward said the government "reluctantly" acknowledged there was no viable path to investigate the vote because ballots had already been counted and were no longer identifiable. Prosecutors said ballots cast for independent candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. had been mixed with other votes, preventing investigators from determining whether some voters intended to support Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan.
The Justice Department sued Alaska on October 22, seeking to block certification if Sullivan lost by a margin smaller than the number of votes cast for Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg. Prosecutors alleged his candidacy was intended to confuse voters and divert Republican support toward Peltola.
US District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on November 1, two days before the election, finding that prosecutors lacked standing because their proposed investigation offered no workable remedy. Alaska officials opposed the challenge, arguing the department lacked authority to interfere with the state's certification process.
Peltola secured 50.13% of first-choice votes in the November 3 election, winning without additional rounds of ranked-choice counting. Her victory was confirmed November 17. The League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause, which intervened in the lawsuit, have asked the Ninth Circuit to affirm the dismissal and consider sanctions against federal attorneys involved in the case.
