Key facts
- Cleta Mitchell told Ed Martin that pardons should move before trials and before defendants faced further expense.
- Mitchell argued a prompt federal pardon could let Georgia's prosecuting attorneys council move to dismiss charges against Trump.
- Trump's November 10, 2025 blanket pardon did not legally affect state-level cases against fake electors.
- The Wisconsin criminal case against three architects of the fake elector scheme is still pending, the Guardian reported.
- American Oversight obtained the emails through a Freedom of Information Act request and provided them to the Guardian.
Emails obtained by the watchdog group American Oversight through a Freedom of Information Act request and provided to the Guardian show that in fall 2025, Cleta Mitchell, a lawyer involved in efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election, pressed Justice Department pardon attorney Ed Martin to move quickly on pardons for people who signed certificates falsely claiming Trump won their states. "Time is of the essence," Mitchell wrote, adding that pardons should move forward before trials were scheduled and before defendants faced further expense and mental anguish. Martin replied: "Thank you for this. Very helpful."
Mitchell argued that a prompt federal pardon could lead Georgia's prosecuting attorneys council to dismiss the remaining charges against Trump, according to the emails. She also wrote that a pardon before an Arizona grand jury could file charges would be optimum to stop the persecution of defendants, including two of Charlie Kirk's top lieutenants at Turning Point USA. Kirk had been slain in Utah weeks earlier.
Trump issued a blanket pardon for the fake electors on November 10, 2025, but the pardon did not legally affect state-level charges. The Wisconsin criminal case against three architects of the fake elector scheme is still pending, while cases in Arizona, Michigan and Nevada have stalled for reasons unrelated to the pardons, the Guardian reported. The day Trump issued the pardons, Martin received an email congratulating him and wrote: "It was a long project. But I am glad we stuck the landing."
Chioma Chukwu, executive director of American Oversight, said the documents shed light on the extent to which Mitchell and other Trump allies used their access to get Trump to act. Mitchell did not respond to a request for comment, the Guardian reported. A person close to the pardon effort said Martin had been pressing and working on the issue for months.