All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
All NewsHome
← Back to US Politics & Policy

Trump Tariffs on Canada Face Legal Hurdles Under Obscure Law

Created at 25 Aug · 3:11 PM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

President Donald Trump has invoked Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, a little-known law, to impose new tariffs on approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports. Experts suggest these tariffs, while potentially flexible, are likely to face significant legal challenges and may be struck down in court.

Key Numbers

50%tariff rate on Canadian imports
$20 billionvalue of targeted Canadian imports
5%of total U.S. imports from Canada
1930year of the Tariff Act invoked
August 19deadline for Canada to reach trade resolutions

Who's Involved

Donald Trump
President who invoked Section 338 tariffs on Canada
Canada
Ally facing new U.S. tariffs under Section 338
International Trade Commission (ITC)
Body tasked with bringing discriminatory actions to the president's attention
Trump Tariffs on Canada Face Legal Hurdles Under Obscure Law

↳ Why This Matters

The invocation of a little-known trade law and the imposition of significant tariffs on a close ally like Canada create uncertainty for supply chains and are likely to lead to legal battles, potentially impacting bilateral trade relations and the effectiveness of future trade policy tools.

Key facts

  • President Donald Trump invoked Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 to impose new tariffs on Canadian goods.
  • The tariffs amount to 50% on approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports.
  • The law allows tariffs when a country imposes "unreasonable charge, exaction, regulation, or limitation" on U.S. goods or discriminates against U.S. commerce.
  • Covered goods cannot claim preferential treatment under the USMCA.
  • Canada has a 30-day negotiation period before the tariffs take effect on August 19.
  • Legal experts believe the tariffs are likely to face and potentially fail in court challenges.

President Donald Trump has invoked Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, a little-known and rarely used law, to impose new tariffs on approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports. The tariffs, set at 50%, target goods ranging from hockey sticks to cement, representing about 5% of total U.S. imports from Canada. These goods will not be eligible for preferential treatment under the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA).

The administration justified the tariffs by citing findings that Canada has imposed "unreasonable charge, exaction, regulation, or limitation" on U.S. goods or discriminated against U.S. commerce. The law allows the president to levy duties "whenever he shall find as a fact" that such discriminatory behavior is occurring, with the International Trade Commission (ITC) tasked to bring such instances to the president's attention.

Canada has until August 19 to negotiate alternative trade resolutions before the tariffs officially go into effect. Despite the potential flexibility of Section 338 as a trade weapon, legal experts express significant doubts about the tariffs' ability to withstand court challenges, suggesting they may be struck down. The move has also raised concerns about U.S.-Canada supply chains and could create new leverage in ongoing USMCA discussions.

Frequently asked questions

Section 338 empowers the president to impose tariffs on foreign countries found to be imposing "unreasonable charge, exaction, regulation, or limitation" on U.S. goods or discriminating against U.S. commerce.

The tariffs cover approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports, including items like hockey sticks and cement, but exclude energy products, potash, critical minerals, and fish.

Canada has until August 19 to reach alternative trade resolutions with the U.S. to avoid the imposition of the 50% tariff.

Legal experts suggest that while the law offers flexibility, the tariffs are legally shaky and likely to be shot down in any court challenge.

What Happens Next

01Canada will engage in negotiations to reach alternative trade resolutions.
02The tariffs are set to take effect on August 19 if no resolution is reached.
03The tariffs are expected to face legal scrutiny and potential court challenges.

How It Developed

President Donald Trump invoked Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 to impose new tariffs on Canadian goods.
The tariffs target approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports, representing 5% of total U.S. imports from Canada.
Covered goods include items like hockey sticks and cement, but exclude energy products, potash, critical minerals, and fish.
Goods subject to the tariffs cannot claim preferential treatment under the USMCA.
Canada has until August 19 to reach alternative trade resolutions to avoid the 50% tariff.
Legal experts express concerns that the tariffs may not survive court challenges.
The tariffs are seen as a potential trade weapon for the Trump administration and could create leverage in USMCA discussions.

Sources

T1
New Canada Tariffs Raise Familiar Legal Risks for TrumpThe New York Times
T2
President Trump Imposes Tariffs on Canada Under Section 338 | Brownsteinbhfs.com
T2
‘Untested, Unused, A Blank Slate’: What to Know About the Section 338 Tariffs | Law.comlaw.com
T2
Trump’s new tariffs on Canada face legal hurdles, experts saythestar.com

Related Stories

Canada retaliates with dollar-for-dollar tariffs as US trade talks collapse
25 Aug · 3:21 PM
US-Canada trade dispute impacts steelmakers, auto manufacturers
25 Aug · 10:11 AM
Canada retaliates with $20B tariffs on US goods amid trade war
24 Aug · 9:31 PM
Canada's Trade Leverage Against US Economy and Trump Detailed
25 Aug · 1:16 AM
Canadian ag groups concerned about US trade tensions
25 Aug · 2:56 PM