Key facts
- Dwayne Wilson, 69, testified that the H dorms at the Dade correctional institution are nicknamed "hell dorm" because concrete walls radiate heat.
- Sensors recorded heat indexes above 88F (31C) 97% of the time, with one reading equivalent to 119F (48C) at 10pm on a July day in 2025.
- Gary Wheeler, 67, testified that a prison nurse told him he had heat exhaustion after he thought he was having a heart attack.
- Dr Susi Vassallo testified that heat contributed to four deaths at the prison, while a medical examiner found James Beam died of pneumonia.
- Defense counsel Mathew Gutierrez argued that the eighth amendment did not cover air conditioning when ratified in 1791.
- The trial is expected to resume next Monday with more prisoner testimony.
Dwayne Wilson, 69, testified on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, about the heat inside the H dorms at the Dade correctional institution, a state prison south of Miami, Florida, that has no air conditioning. He described cells where the walls radiate heat and said prisoners put water on the floor to try to stay cool. The testimony came during a bench trial that began on Monday, November 16, 2026, at a federal courthouse in downtown Miami.
Wilson is among a group of prisoners who sued the Florida department of corrections in 2024 over conditions at the prison, alleging that extreme heat contributed to four deaths and subjected prisoners to cruel and unusual punishment. The Florida Justice Institute, the plaintiffs' law firm, obtained a judge's permission to install 31 sensors throughout the prison during the summer of 2025. Stefano Shiavon, a professor of civil and environmental engineering, used the readings to calculate heat indexes that were above 88F (31C) 97% of the time, with one reading in the H dorm dayroom equivalent to 119F (48C) at 10pm on a July day in 2025.
Gary Wheeler, 67, who was also housed in the H dorms, testified that a prison nurse told him he had heat exhaustion after he thought he was having a heart attack. Both men said they filed informal grievances about the heat, some dating back to at least 2019. They also described James "Jim" Beam, an 83-year-old wheelchair-bound inmate with a respiratory condition who died within days of a night when Wilson found him on the floor and helped him to the medical clinic. A medical examiner's report found Beam died of pneumonia, but Dr Susi Vassallo, an emergency medicine physician and medical toxicologist, testified that she believed long-term heat exposure contributed to his death and to three other deaths at the prison.
Attorneys for the Dade correctional institution argued during cross-examination that more than 100 ceiling and exhaust fans helped mitigate heat and that the eighth amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment was not relevant. Mathew Gutierrez, defense counsel for the Florida department of corrections, FDC secretary Ricky Dixon and warden Francisco Acosta, said in his opening statement that air conditioning did not exist when the eighth amendment was ratified in 1791. The defense also said prisoners could wear shorts and had access to water jugs with ice, though prisoners said the ice melted quickly in coolers filled with hot shower water. Vassallo said fans can increase body temperature at certain temperatures.
The trial is expected to resume next Monday, when more prisoners will testify. The prison can hold up to 1,500 people.