Key facts
- Proposed legislation would make it a crime to possess or use batteries that fail safety standards and ban storing batteries inside apartments.
- Fire Department Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore said the administration has significant concerns about unintended consequences for delivery workers.
- Bonsignore said delivery workers could lose their livelihoods through confiscation of the devices they use daily to earn a living.
- The Senate bill, sponsored by Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand, has already passed the House of Representatives.
- Britain has focused on sellers of batteries and devices, strengthening responsibility of online marketplaces and removing unsafe products from sale, a government spokesperson said.
- City Council Speaker Julie Menin called the Sunset Park and South Bronx fires heartbreaking tragedies that underscore the urgent need for action.
The New York City Council held a three-hour emergency hearing on Friday, November 20, on a set of stricter rules for e-bike storage and battery safety, after 10 people died in two recent New York fires. At least one of those fires was determined to be caused by e-bike batteries.
The proposed legislation would make it a crime to possess or use batteries that do not meet safety standards and would ban storing batteries inside apartments. It is unclear whether the measures will advance. Officials in Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration, including from the New York City Fire Department, criticized the proposals, saying they would penalize everyday riders and low-income delivery workers.
Fire Department Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore said the administration had "significant concerns of unintended consequences that would most heavily impact delivery workers, many of whom are immigrants, with limited English proficiency." She said delivery workers "could face losing their livelihoods and having their lives upended through the confiscation of the device they use every day to make a living."
Lithium-ion battery fires have become an international concern since e-bikes and e-scooters soared in popularity during the COVID-19 pandemic. Many of those batteries are now aging, which fire officials say is likely adding to the number of fires. Britain has focused on sellers of batteries and devices that use them. A British government spokesperson said in response to Reuters questions that unsafe e-bike and e-scooter batteries pose a serious fire risk, which is why the government is strengthening the responsibility of online marketplaces and working with local authorities to remove unsafe products from sale.
In the United States, the Senate unanimously passed legislation on Thursday sponsored by New York's senators, Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand, that would direct the Consumer Product Safety Commission to set mandatory safety standards for lithium-ion batteries used in e-bikes and other micromobility devices. The commission proposed mandatory safety standards for the batteries in June, after a public meeting in 2023. The House of Representatives has already passed the bill.
A commission staff report published in April found 45 deaths from 2017 to 2024 linked to lithium-ion battery fires involving micromobility devices: 19 tied to e-bikes, 15 to e-scooters and 11 to self-balancing scooters or hoverboards.
The issue is particularly acute in New York, where lithium-ion battery fires have reached a record this year. There were 406 such fires through early November, up from 241 in the same period last year, according to Fire Department figures cited by the City Council.
On October 28, an e-bike battery ignited in an apartment in a public housing project in the Bronx, killing four people including an 11-year-old boy. The e-bike was near the doorway, blocking the family's escape, Bonsignore said at the time. About a week later, a fire in Sunset Park, a working-class Brooklyn neighborhood, killed six people and injured at least seven. Investigators have not determined the cause, but fire officials said two charred e-bikes were removed from the building and batteries were found in debris.
City Council Speaker Julie Menin said at the time that the recent building fires in Sunset Park and in the South Bronx, which collectively claimed the lives of 10 New Yorkers, are heartbreaking tragedies that underscore the urgent need for action to prevent further loss of life.

