Key facts
- UCLH excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice in March 2023 over the risk he posed to children, the Guardian reported.
- Hindmarsh wrote an expert report in August 2023 used in the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas.
- Tamara Thomas was sentenced in June 2026 to three years and nine months for gross negligence manslaughter and neglect.
- Damion Thomas was found not guilty of manslaughter but guilty of neglect and sentenced to two years and nine months.
- The Thomases have applied to the court of appeal for permission to appeal against the convictions.
- Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian's questions about the GMC investigation and his exclusion.
Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a consultant in paediatric endocrinology, was excluded from clinical practice by his employer, University College London hospitals trust, in March 2023, during the main trial of Lucy Letby, the Guardian reported on November 21, 2026. The jury, which five months later convicted Letby of murdering seven babies, was never told of the exclusion. UCLH's medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, told the General Medical Council that the hospital could not accept the level of risk Hindmarsh appeared to pose to children and young people.
Hindmarsh went on to produce an expert report in August 2023 that the Crown Prosecution Service used in its case against Damion and Tamara Thomas, two Birmingham parents accused of neglecting their son Joshua, 12, before his death on December 10, 2022. In the report Hindmarsh concluded that Joshua's symptoms at 4am on December 9, 2022 should have prompted an earlier call for medical help. Tamara Thomas was convicted in March 2026 of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect and sentenced in June to three years and nine months in prison. Damion Thomas was found not guilty of manslaughter but guilty of neglect and sentenced to two years and nine months.
The Thomases have always maintained their innocence and have applied to the court of appeal for permission to appeal against the convictions. Their elder son, Alessandro, 27, who is representing them, said they were unaware throughout Hindmarsh's two and a half years of involvement in the case that he was under investigation by the GMC and barred from treating patients.
The Guardian reported that Hindmarsh appears not to have told West Midlands police of the investigation when he wrote his report, and that the CPS West Midlands region office apparently remained unaware of the GMC investigation until Hindmarsh disclosed details after being asked, in December 2025. Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian's questions about the GMC investigation, his exclusion from clinical practice or when he disclosed it to the police. Tim Green KC, a specialist in disclosure, said experts have a duty under criminal procedure rules to disclose undermining material as soon as reasonably practicable.