Key facts
- Birmingham has more than 34,000 supported exempt accommodation residents in about 12,200 properties, against 22,000 in London.
- The review found 12,700 live cases awaiting checks that care, support and supervision were provided after tenancy start.
- Some supported exempt accommodation housing benefit claims were active for more than a decade, some over 20 years, without eligibility checks, the review found.
- Birmingham city council said the review provides assurance its housing benefit assessment process is robust.
- The council said there is no adequate regulation for it to effectively regulate the sector in Birmingham.
- A government spokesperson said it is actively considering next steps on supported housing in Birmingham.
Home secretary Shabana Mahmood said she "smells a rat" over supported exempt accommodation in her Birmingham Ladywood constituency, telling the Birmingham Mail that the use and abuse of the sector is causing many of the issues in her communities. She said she was talking to work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden about the enhanced housing benefits that fund the sector.
Supported exempt accommodation provides housing plus care, support and supervision to vulnerable people, including people with addiction, women fleeing domestic abuse and former prisoners. Birmingham has more than 34,000 residents in the sector across about 12,200 properties, compared with 22,000 in London, whose population is seven times larger.
An independent review commissioned by the council's cross-party audit committee and published in the week of November 16 found the council paid £404.4 million in supported exempt accommodation housing benefit in the year commencing April 2024, and a further £211.8 million in the four months from April 2026, totalling more than £615 million across 15 months. It concluded the council's approach was not fully effective and that risks were not always effectively managed.
The review found 12,700 live cases awaiting a review to prove care, support and supervision were being given after tenancy commenced, meaning payments continued without timely evidence that support was provided. In some cases claims were active for more than a decade, some more than 20 years, without eligibility checks.
Labour councillor Marcus Bernasconi backed an independent investigation, saying the review showed the council had "totally lost control of supported accommodation with the bill for the taxpayer running into the hundreds of millions of pounds with no idea if genuine support is being provided".
A Birmingham city council spokesperson said the review provides assurance that its process for assessing housing benefit claims is robust and includes additional controls beyond other councils, and sets out measures it will implement to improve monitoring. The spokesperson said there remains no adequate regulation for the council to effectively regulate the sector. A government spokesperson said it has been monitoring issues around supported housing in Birmingham and is actively considering next steps, and that legislation to strengthen regulation, including a new licensing scheme, was passed in 2023 but remains under consultation.