Key facts
- An internal expert report found 19 patients died from serious adverse events caused by surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary between 2015 and 2021.
- The 2022 review put the death rate in liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen as high as 18% between 2017 and 2020, against a national average of 2-3%.
- Habib alleged senior officials at NHS Grampian failed to act quickly enough and called for a police investigation into corporate homicide.
- Swinney said the disclosures were of the gravest concern but declined to back a criminal investigation.
- Skaife-Knight said NHS Grampian would consider any new evidence through clinical, governance and legal processes.
- Healthcare Improvement Scotland's report identified one patient death due to a serious adverse event at the board.
A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary called on November 19, 2026, for a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian, the health board that runs the hospital, after an internal expert report found that 19 patients died from serious adverse events caused by surgery between 2015 and 2021.
Dr Mohammed Habib said he had repeatedly reported concerns about the hospital's liver and pancreatic surgery from 2021 onwards and believed dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily. He alleged that senior officials at NHS Grampian failed to take the correct action quickly enough, and called for a police investigation into corporate homicide. His solicitor, Aamer Anwar, published the board's internal report on Thursday, November 19, 2026.
The two external experts who carried out the review in 2022, surgery professors at Edinburgh and Leeds universities, concluded that the death rate in liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen between 2017 and 2020 ran as high as 18%, against a national average of 2-3% for the speciality depending on the patient's condition. Habib, who still works at the hospital, flagged four further deaths during or after surgery since that report was completed. In March 2026, another external expert told hospital executives that persistent high mortality in complex surgery was a red-flag indicator of systemic failure, and the liver and pancreatic surgery department was shut down.
At first minister's questions, John Swinney said Habib's disclosures were of the gravest concern and that the NHS had legal duties to give patients the best possible care and to investigate safety allegations quickly. He rebuffed a demand from Michael Marra, the Scottish Labour leader, for a criminal investigation into what Marra called systemic failures at NHS Grampian. Marra said the families of the 19 people who died deserve answers and justice. Swinney denied the government had ignored Habib's complaints and said the recent decision to demand leadership changes and urgent reforms at the board should produce the necessary improvements.
Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive of NHS Grampian, said a thorough investigation had already taken place, with some elements ongoing, and that any new evidence would be carefully considered through clinical, governance and legal processes. She said duty of candour processes are followed where reviews identify issues around patient care, including direct communication with patients and families where required.
Habib said he had repeatedly contacted the police, Scottish government ministers and Scotland's independent whistleblowing officer but was rebuffed or told the cases he raised were time-barred. Anwar said the Lord Advocate, Ruth Charteris KC, should instruct her lawyers and Police Scotland to launch a criminal investigation, and that ministers should immediately place NHS Grampian into special measures.
Angela Constance, the Scottish health secretary, told MSPs that NHS Grampian faced being put into special measures if its reforms were not introduced quickly or effectively enough. A Healthcare Improvement Scotland report found very serious shortcomings in the board's leadership, including failing to be transparent and accurate in its accounts of its actions, but identified only one patient death due to a serious adverse event. A Scottish government spokesperson said any criminal investigation is a matter for Police Scotland. Police Scotland has been approached for comment.