Key facts
- Wölken's lawyer Carsten Zatschler told the General Court it was not credible there were zero emails on the procedure.
- The Commission said Wölken's request did not specify he sought internal emails predating the decision.
- Commission lawyer Tim Maxian Rusche said the institution faces more and more fishing expeditions in document requests.
- The Commission handed over 14 documents to Wölken, mostly emails and position papers from outside stakeholders sent after the decision.
- The withdrawal was announced the same day Vance met von der Leyen at an AI summit in Paris.
- Judges did not confirm when a decision would be made in the case.
The European Commission was accused Wednesday at a hearing at the EU's General Court in Luxembourg of withholding internal messages that explain why it dropped a contentious patent proposal, amid claims of pressure from U.S. Vice President JD Vance. German center-left MEP Tiemo Wölken asked the Commission for internal notes on why the proposal was abruptly killed in early 2025. He was told there was only one relevant internal document, minutes of a private meeting between heads of cabinet, which the Commission refused to hand over.
Wölken's lawyer Carsten Zatschler said it was "unbelievable" that there were "zero emails on this highly-politicized, economically-relevant procedure." He said: "All of this apparently happened without any form of electronic communication. That's quite simply not credible." Zatschler also asked whether a meeting between von der Leyen and Vance played a role in the withdrawal.
In February 2025, the Commission announced it was withdrawing plans for a standard essential patents regulation on the licensing of patents, saying there was no "clear signal of support" from co-legislators. Negotiations between the European Parliament and EU countries were ongoing at the time. The proposal was officially killed in July that year. The withdrawal was announced on the same day that Vance met von der Leyen at an AI summit in Paris, where they discussed AI, Ukraine and transatlantic ties.
The proposal had triggered a lobbying battle between patent holders including Nokia, Ericsson, Qualcomm and Huawei and companies that license their technology, from phone makers to carmakers. Wölken told POLITICO his team had met the Polish presidency of the Council of the EU just days before the decision and no one was informed.
Lawyers for the Commission told judges that Wölken's request did not specify that he was seeking internal emails predating the decision. Tim Maxian Rusche, representing the Commission, said the institution is "being exposed to more and more fishing expeditions" with "very general" questions in access to document requests. The Commission handed over 14 documents to Wölken, most of which were emails and position papers from outside stakeholders sent after the decision was announced.
The Commission also faces a lawsuit from the European Parliament over the decision to kill the proposal. Lawmakers voted last year to sue, arguing the Commission had overstepped its competence. German Social Democrat René Repasi said the Commission's right to withdraw a proposal "cannot be used as a political instrument to short-circuit Parliament's work." The judges did not confirm when a decision would be made in the case.
