Key facts
- Ofcom is investigating Meta Platforms for potential breaches of UK online safety laws regarding Instagram Instants.
- Meta argues Category 1 obligations under the Online Safety Act are designed for public-facing social media, not encrypted messaging services.
- Meta is also challenging Ofcom's funding model and penalty structure for safety breaches.
- Other companies like Roblox and Quora are contesting Ofcom's categorization choices.
- The EU has launched an antitrust inquiry into Meta's AI advancements on WhatsApp.
Britain's communications regulator, Ofcom, has opened its first formal investigation into Meta Platforms under the Online Safety Act. The probe questions whether Meta properly assessed risks associated with its Instagram Instants feature before its May launch.
Meta is engaged in a legal challenge against the Act, arguing that its stringent Category 1 obligations, designed for public-facing social media, are being inappropriately applied to encrypted messaging services like WhatsApp. Meta contends that these requirements are incompatible with the privacy-focused nature of end-to-end encrypted communication. This pushback, shared by other companies like Roblox and Quora, has reportedly delayed the full enforcement of the Act beyond April 2025.
Meta is also contesting Ofcom's funding model, which bases regulatory fees on companies' worldwide revenue, arguing it is disproportionate to UK operations. Additionally, the company disputes the penalty structure, which allows for fines up to 10% of global revenue or 18 million pounds for safety breaches, deeming it punitive overreach for localized infractions. Ofcom, however, maintains that such penalties are necessary to influence large tech firms and mirror standard practices in the UK telecoms sector.
Governments globally are closely monitoring this legal battle, as an Ofcom victory could set a precedent for regulators to impose stricter content controls and tax global revenues of tech companies, including those with encrypted services. Conversely, Meta securing concessions could highlight weaknesses in current legislative frameworks for digital products. The European Union has also initiated an antitrust probe into Meta's integration of AI features within WhatsApp, citing concerns about potential barriers for third-party AI innovators.
