Federal judge rules Flock license plate searches unconstitutional

Judge Hill stated that the deputy had no apparent reason to search for the woman's license plate, other than it being from California. The deputy subsequently used information from the Flock search to justify searching the woman's car, where 91 pounds of methamphetamine were allegedly found. However, Judge Hill ordered that all evidence obtained following the Flock search must be suppressed as 'fruit of a poisonous tree'.

Broader concerns about warrantless Flock database searches were also raised by Judge Hill, who described the practice as 'indiscriminate mass surveillance.' She noted that the technology collects information on all vehicles passing by its cameras and provides this data to law enforcement on demand, unlike more targeted surveillance methods.

This ruling aligns with growing criticism of Flock technology from various political viewpoints. Several state and local governments, including those in Florida and Texas, have announced plans to cease using Flock. Additionally, Senator Bernie Sanders has introduced the Block Flock Act, aiming to prohibit federal agencies from utilizing automated license plate readers.

Flock CEO Garretty Langley has acknowledged concerns about privacy and safety, offering an apology for instances where law enforcement has allegedly used the system to stalk women. In response to increasing cancellations, Flock has reportedly begun offering voluntary employee buyouts.