Key facts
- Aria chief executive Annabelle Herd said the reported scheme is unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit AI companies' commercial interests.
- Australian Writers' Guild chief executive Claire Pullen said she could not see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind.
- The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance said it would be alarmed at the reported proposal and demanded protections apply to all creative sectors.
- Shadow attorney general Michaelia Cash said the proposal would divide the rightsholders and should be strongly resisted.
- Attorney general Michelle Rowland's spokesperson said the government has long advocated commercial deals between tech companies and Australian artists.
- Guardian Australia said it could not independently verify details of the proposal.
Australia's music industry said on November 19 it would reject a reported proposal to let AI companies train on Australian content under paid permits while exempting music, saying the creative community would stay united against it.
The Australian Financial Review reported on November 19 that the government was considering the copyright change, under which AI companies would buy permits to train on Australian content but music may be exempted. Guardian Australia said it was not able to independently verify details of the proposal.
Annabelle Herd, chief executive of the Australian Recording Industry Association, said she was unaware of the proposal before November 19 and that the music industry would not desert other creatives. "Had we been consulted, we would have advised this scheme is unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit the commercial interests of AI companies, not protect creators," she told Guardian Australia. Claire Pullen, chief executive of the Australian Writers' Guild, said: "I can't see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind."
Herd and Pullen said such a scheme would be difficult to implement technically, questioning how content such as movies or TV shows, which combine copyrighted music, video and screenwriting, would be treated if one element were exempted. Pullen said AI companies had an open invitation to negotiate for years and had refused to talk.
The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance said it would be alarmed at the reported proposal and demanded that protections promised by prime minister Anthony Albanese apply to all creative sectors. The Albanese government would not comment on the reported proposal.
Senior Labor figures have pointed to what they describe as shortfalls in copyright law. Industry minister Tim Ayres said on November 17 that the status quo is no good for creative workers, a line acting prime minister Richard Marles repeated on November 19, adding on News24 that people are being ripped off. A spokesperson for attorney general Michelle Rowland said the government has long advocated commercial deals between tech companies and Australian artists.
Opposition and crossbench parliamentarians also rejected the idea. Shadow attorney general Michaelia Cash said the proposal would divide the rightsholders and should be strongly resisted. Independent senator David Pocock described it as a divide and conquer strategy, and Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young urged the government not to meet copyright demands from big tech.