Key facts
- The Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed the UK government issued a technical capability notice to Apple.
- The Home Office argued disclosure would damage national security and cited a policy of neither confirming nor denying security matters.
- Britain issued an initial notice in January 2025, dropped it after negotiations with the Trump administration, then issued a second in July 2025.
- The tribunal said the respondent had not established that revealing the notice would be damaging to national security.
- A trial to decide the substance of Apple's challenge is not expected until next year.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on November 19, 2026 that the Home Office had not established that revealing the existence of a technical capability notice issued to Apple would damage national security. The tribunal confirmed in open court that the notice had been issued, rejecting arguments made on behalf of Britain's interior ministry.
The government had argued it could not comment on the existence of such an order because disclosure would damage national security and because it operated a policy of neither confirming nor denying security matters. In January 2025, Britain issued an initial technical capability notice seeking a back door to allow access to encrypted cloud backups of data belonging to US and British citizens. That demand was dropped following months of negotiations with US President Donald Trump's administration, but in July 2025 Britain issued a second notice that applied only to Apple's UK customers.
Apple launched a renewed challenge against the government at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal but has been unable to give public details on why because of legal restrictions. The tribunal's ruling on November 19, 2026 considered only whether the notice could be publicly acknowledged; a trial to decide the substance of the case is not expected until next year.
Earlier in the proceedings, the Home Office sought an order on February 28, 2025 that the bare details of the case be kept private, including by not appearing on the tribunal's website. The tribunal made an interim order in those terms, set directions on March 3, 2025 and listed a hearing for March 14, 2025. The tribunal heard submissions from Daniel Beard KC for Apple and Sir James Eadie KC for the Home Office, and handed down a public judgment on April 7, 2025 rejecting the Home Office's application to keep the case private.
