Key facts
- Jilska Williams said she believes her husband's cancer was a definite probability linked to the lagoon chemicals.
- Eleven firefighters or their families raised health concerns with a BBC investigation into the 1980 fire.
- Former firefighter Jim MacGrane said six wives had miscarriages within 12 to 15 months of the incident.
- Prof Anna Stec said linking specific chemicals to health disorders is very difficult and called for more research.
- Wrexham council, which owns the site, said it does not meet the legal definition of contaminated land and is regularly inspected.
- The Fire Brigades' Union said it is consulting scientists on options to support the retired firefighters.
Jilska Williams said she believes the rare lung cancer that killed her husband may have stemmed from chemicals he swallowed when he fell into a burning toxic waste lagoon near Wrexham in north Wales in August 1980. Steve Williams, then in his 20s, was one of 60 firefighters sent to tackle the blaze at the Llwyneinion lagoon, which was sending thick black smoke over a nearby village. He slipped in and was pulled out.
Steve Williams was checked at hospital after falling in and given a tetanus injection before being sent home, his widow said. The couple later moved to Melbourne in Australia, and in 1994 he was diagnosed with stage four small cell carcinoma and given weeks to live. He died three days after the couple's 17th wedding anniversary, aged 39, leaving two children aged six and 10. "It's a definite probability," Jilska Williams, 71, said of a link to the chemicals. "Someone should be held accountable."
Eleven firefighters or their families told a BBC investigation about concerns the fire could have had an impact on their health. They said there was an increased number of miscarriages among partners of those who attended the fire in the year after, and highlighted concerns about rates of cancers since. Jim MacGrane, 71, a firefighter at Wrexham at the time, said six wives had miscarriages within 12 to 15 months of the incident. Mark Jones, 68, said a significant number of the 60 who attended had cancers or died with cancer; his father Ken, who also attended, died of lymph and brain cancer in 2011.
Andy Moore, 70, who spent the day bringing in foam to help smother the fire and saw Steve Williams fall in, said firefighters were not equipped to face the chemicals in the lagoon. "There was no request for chemical PPE, we were basically fighting that fire in our normal tunics, drips and helmets," he said. He said he was diagnosed with skin cancer a year ago and did not know whether it could be related to the incident.
Wrexham council, which owns the site, said that while it did not meet the legal definition of contaminated land, it regularly inspected and monitored the area. Prof Anna Stec, a University of Leicester expert in fire chemistry and toxicity, said it was very difficult to link specific chemicals to health disorders and that with firefighters it is even harder because they can be exposed to a cocktail of toxic substances over their careers. She said there should be more research into what happened at Llwyneinion, citing patterns seen in the Firefighters' Cancer and Disease Registry.
The Llwyneinion site was a dumping ground for chemicals suspected to have included cancer-causing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) from chemical giant Monsanto, according to the report. The BBC said its Sheen's Buried programme team found elevated levels of PCBs in soil samples taken in an area open to the public beyond the fenced-off lagoon, as well as at 13 other suspected dumpsites for the firm's toxic waste across the country. The lagoon was purchased by the then Clwyd County Council for just £1 in May 1980 and remains fenced off.
The BBC reported that the group of Llwyneinion firefighters are set to meet representatives from the Fire Brigades' Union later this week. Gareth Tovey of the FBU said the union was taking the matter seriously, was consulting with scientists to discuss options to support the retired firefighters, and would write to Wales' fire and rescue services to ask about protections in place for those called to sites linked to historical dumping of toxic waste.