Key facts
- Trump said Washington would catch up to China on rare earth supplies within 10 months.
- Jack Lifton of the Critical Minerals Institute called the 10-month target unrealistic and diplomatic bluster.
- Lifton said the US will not match China in rare earths production, processing or end-user manufacturing in 10 years.
US President Donald Trump said on November 17, 2026 that Washington would catch up to China on rare earth supplies within 10 months. The claim drew a direct challenge from Jack Lifton, co-chairman of the Critical Minerals Institute, a global think tank.
"The US will not catch up with China in rare earths production, processing or end-user rare earth-enabled product manufacturing in the next 10 months or the next 10 years," Lifton said. The report described his assessment as calling the 10-month target unrealistic and diplomatic bluster, citing Beijing's decades-long dominance in rare earth supply chains.
The report did not state what steps, funding or policy measures the US administration has attached to the 10-month target, and gave no response from the White House to Lifton's assessment.
