Key facts
- Disney lawyers accused Trump administration officials of "blatant violations of the US constitution" and censorship.
- The accusation came during the first court hearing over the FCC's early review of Disney's eight local television station licenses.
- Disney argues the FCC's actions, at the behest of Chair Brendan Carr, are intended to chill the network's speech.
- ABC has reportedly stopped booking politicians on 'The View' and aired a Trump speech on streaming to avoid antagonizing the administration.
- The FCC argued the early renewal order is a "tool" to expedite a review of ABC for potential violations of equal opportunities regulations.
Disney lawyers accused the Trump administration of "blatant violations of the US constitution" and censorship during the first court hearing over the Federal Communications Commission’s early review of the media giant’s eight local television station licenses. District judge Loren AliKhan presided over the two-hour hearing and took the matter "under advisement" without issuing an order.
Lawyers for ABC, Disney, and its station group argued that the FCC’s actions, taken at the behest of Donald Trump-appointed chair Brendan Carr, were intended to chill the network’s speech, which the president and Carr have argued is tilted against the administration. The network cited past threats by the president and the FCC chairman that jeopardized the licenses of television networks, including ABC, for editorial purposes. "These are blatant violations of the US constitution," said prominent trial lawyer Beth Wilkinson, arguing for ABC, adding that the network faces a "chilling effect" impacting its editorial decision-making, leading it to steer clear of political bookings or programming that could provoke ire from the Trump administration and Carr. ABC has stated it stopped booking politicians on "The View" and aired a July speech by Trump on its streaming platform to avoid antagonizing the president.
Representing the FCC defendants, Dimitar P Georgiev argued that there was "no reason to believe the early renewal order has prompted changes to the plaintiffs’ editorial decisions." He also contended that the US district court for the District of Columbia was not the proper jurisdiction for the case. Georgiev stated that the license renewal process was not about the licenses themselves but served as a "tool" to expedite the commission’s review of ABC for potential violations of federal equal opportunities regulations. Judge AliKhan questioned why the FCC determined ABC's responses to document requests were "woefully inadequate" only in the summer, and why all eight stations' renewal applications were required simultaneously. She also noted past comments by Carr suggesting that ABC's decision not to carry President Trump's July speech on its linear channel could factor into the license investigation.