Key facts
- The Home Office admitted in a court order it had adopted an unduly narrow approach to the concept of exploitation.
- Work Rights Centre said 74% of more than 100 migrant care workers it surveyed had experienced some form of financial exploitation.
- The worker was supported by Work Rights Centre and Central England Law Centre in his challenge to the home secretary.
- Solicitor Tessa Burwood said compliance checks for the health and care visa scheme are meant to stop exploitation by non-genuine agencies.
- A Home Office spokesperson said the financial exploitation of visa applicants and visa holders is completely unacceptable.
Migrant workers who are financially exploited can now be considered victims of modern slavery, after a legal challenge brought by a care worker who paid £22,000 to an agent for a UK care home job that did not exist, according to a report dated November 17, 2026.
The care worker, identified only as Ali, from Pakistan, was put in touch with the agent by a friend who said the agent had helped him secure a UK care job. After paying the £22,000, he obtained what he believed was a genuine certificate of sponsorship and a health and care skilled worker visa from the Home Office, and moved to the UK with his wife and two young children in October 2023. He had borrowed heavily from family members to cover the cost.
After arriving, he kept calling the number he had been given about starting work. He was eventually told to go to a car showroom, where a man told him he had been scammed and that others in a similar situation had been sent to him. The friend who recommended the agent told him no job had materialized for him either and that he had returned to Pakistan.
"At that moment I felt like my whole life had just started to cave in," Ali said in a witness statement. "We had invested everything we had and got into very heavy debts on the basis of this care worker job." He said the family was left destitute and that stress turned his hair white and cost him two stone in weight.
Luke Piper, head of immigration at the charity Work Rights Centre, said it had encountered many other cases of financial exploitation of migrant workers. In a survey of more than 100 migrant care workers by the charity, 74% reported some form of financial exploitation. "There is a worrying disconnect between those experiencing modern slavery and those getting help," Piper said.
Ali was referred to the national referral mechanism for potential victims of trafficking and modern slavery and was initially found not to qualify. Supported by Work Rights Centre and Central England Law Centre, he challenged the home secretary for not listing financial exploitation among forms of modern slavery. A judicial review was issued earlier this year, and the decision was reversed so the Home Office will consider his case as one of potential human trafficking.
The Home Office admitted in a court order that it had previously "adopted an unduly narrow approach to the concept of exploitation" and said it would recognize financial exploitation as a form of modern slavery and trafficking. Tessa Burwood, the solicitor at Central England Law Centre who represented Ali, said compliance checks for the health and care visa scheme are meant to ensure vulnerable migrant care workers are employed only by genuine agencies. "Something has gone seriously wrong here," she said, adding that recognition of financial exploitation is "a small step in the right direction" but not the end of the difficulties for migrant care workers.
A Home Office spokesperson said: "While we do not comment on operational matters, the financial exploitation of visa applicants and visa holders is completely unacceptable." The spokesperson said the department works with enforcement and safeguarding partners where evidence of abuse is identified.