Key facts
- Three justices, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, voted to take up the challenge; four were required.
- Thomas, joined by Alito, wrote that First Amendment protections do not give way because a state heavily regulates speech.
- California requires licensed physicians to complete at least 50 hours of continuing medical education every two years.
- Khatibi said she teaches CME courses that meet all California requirements except the implicit bias mandate.
- California told the justices that granting review would imperil medical regulations designed to protect patient health.
The Supreme Court declined on November 16 to take up a free-speech challenge to California's requirement that instructors teaching doctors renewing their medical licenses cover implicit bias, according to The Hill. Three conservative justices, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, wanted to hear the case, but four votes are required.
Ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi and Do No Harm, a group that combats diversity initiatives in medicine, brought the challenge. They argued California is compelling instructors to deliver a contested ideological message in violation of their First Amendment rights. Lower courts ruled the medical courses amount to the government's own speech, which the First Amendment does not regulate, and allowed the requirement to proceed.
Thomas, joined by Alito, wrote that the lower courts' logic fundamentally misunderstands the Court's precedents and the Constitution, adding that First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a state heavily regulates speech. Gorsuch dissented separately without explaining his reasoning.
California requires licensed physicians to complete at least 50 hours of continuing medical education every two years. The dispute concerns a requirement state lawmakers passed in 2019 that all courses contain curriculum covering the understanding of implicit bias. Khatibi said she frequently teaches such courses and that they comply with all of California's requirements except the implicit bias mandate.
California urged the justices to deny the appeal, saying the lower rulings are consistent with Supreme Court precedent and that intervention would imperil medical regulations designed to protect patient health. State officials wrote that granting review and entertaining the petitioners' constitutional theory would threaten to transform regulation of the medical profession.
