Key facts
- The plan covers 2,056 public housing apartments at Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea Houses, which NYCHA would continue to own.
- Private developers would add about 3,500 mixed-income apartments, with current tenants' rent held at 30% of income.
- The administration says NYCHA faces about $78 billion in repair needs, and conversion cash flow is one of the few ways to pay for them.
- The DSA resolution won 44% of the floor vote after 37% backed it in a pre-convention survey.
- The resolution said Related Companies is scheduled to make hundreds of millions of dollars from federal funding and rents through the project.
- More than two dozen families, including many seniors, are refusing to move, according to the report.
Delegates to the New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America voted down a resolution opposing Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to demolish and rebuild two Manhattan public housing developments at their convention on November 14, 2026. It was the only one of nine resolutions to fail at a convention attended by more than 430 delegates. Mamdani did not attend.
The plan covers 2,056 apartments at Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea Houses, with the New York City Housing Authority still owning the buildings. Private developers would then add about 3,500 mixed-income apartments, and current tenants would get new apartments under private management with rent held at 30% of income. The administration says NYCHA faces about $78 billion in repair needs and that conversion cash flow is one of the few ways to pay for them.
The fix has circulated for years, first under former Mayor Bill de Blasio. Under Eric Adams, NYCHA announced in December 2021 that resident leaders had selected Related Companies and Essence Development as development partners. NYCHA began issuing relocation notices in July 2025, and two buildings are designated for demolition in the first phase.
The DSA resolution said Related Companies is scheduled to make hundreds of millions of dollars from federal funding and rents through the project, and that residents have called it a land grab. It called the buildings structurally sound and criticized Related for withholding structural analyses. Three tenants joined DSA and were elected delegates with the backing of the chapter's Tenant Organizing Working Group. "We have no interest in being privatized," Celines Miranda, one of the new delegates, told Gothamist. "We have no interest in being demolished."
Tenants and neighbors tried to stop the project in court. In July, a state appeals court upheld rulings denying their requests for preliminary injunctions, finding the challenge was filed after the four-month deadline that began when NYCHA issued its July 2025 decision to proceed. The court also ruled that relocation, while inconvenient and difficult, especially for seniors, did not amount to irreparable harm. More than two dozen families, including many seniors, are refusing to move, according to the report.
Cea Weaver, who leads the Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants and is a DSA member, told Gothamist that leaving the housing in its current disrepair is unacceptable given her socialist values, and said the activists do not speak for all residents. Matt Rauschenbach, a Mamdani spokesman, said in a statement last month: "Too many leaders have walked away from public housing. We are not going to." The resolution won 44% of the floor vote after 37% backed it in a pre-convention survey.
