Key facts
- Land & Buildings said Invitation Homes shares trade at roughly $270,000 per home versus about $460,000 for homes it sold since December 2025.
- The fund estimated net asset value at about $45 a share, more than 65% above the trading price after 6% selling costs.
- Land & Buildings wants at least $2 billion a year returned to shareholders on a leverage-neutral basis, funded by home sales.
- The plan offers tenants a 6% rebate toward a down payment if they buy the home they rent.
- Land & Buildings said Invitation Homes paid more than $79 million to settle four legal matters, including $48 million with the FTC in 2024.
- Invitation Homes did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the letter.
Land & Buildings Investment Management released an open letter to shareholders on November 16 urging Invitation Homes to accelerate home sales, return at least $2 billion a year to shareholders and curtail acquisitions and development. The Stamford, Connecticut-based fund, led by Jonathan Litt, said it owns an undisclosed stake in Invitation Homes, the largest US owner of single-family rental homes with more than 80,000 properties.
The letter argues the public market values Invitation Homes' houses at roughly $270,000 each, against an average sale price of about $460,000 on homes the company has sold since December 2025, a discount of about 40%. Land & Buildings said it valued more than 90% of the wholly owned portfolio address by address and estimated an average value of about $425,000 per home, supporting a net asset value estimate of about $45 a share, more than 65% above the trading price after assuming 6% selling costs.
"REITs with sound fundamentals and no distressed assets do not trade at such a discount indefinitely. Something has to give," the firm said in the letter, which was disseminated via GlobeNewswire.
The fund said Invitation Homes has lagged the S&P 500, the broader REIT index, American Homes 4 Rent and the peer group the board uses for executive compensation over one, three and five years. It said the stock ranks second to last in that compensation group over three years, trailing the average by more than 35 percentage points, and that five-year holders have lost more than 20% including dividends. Land & Buildings put the implied capitalization rate at about 7%, roughly 60 basis points wider than American Homes 4 Rent.
