Key facts
- The court asked whether earlier home seller settlements are a valid benchmark for the buyer settlements, given those resolved both buyer and seller claims.
- The judge asked how each defendant's ability to pay and transaction volume shaped its settlement amount.
- Settling parties must file briefs on the five topics by December 14, 2026, after which the court will weigh further responses.
- The court found the opt-in agreements compensate indirect purchaser claims at almost the same rate as the Burnett, Gibson, Keel and Hooper seller settlements.
- The National Association of Realtors did not immediately return HousingWire's request for comment.
A US court declined to grant final approval to the Tuccori homebuyer commission settlements at a hearing earlier in November 2026, saying it needed a closer look at how the agreements were reached before ruling, HousingWire reported on November 16, 2026.
The settlements cover the National Association of Realtors at $52.25 million, Compass at $7.33 million, eXp World Holdings at $4.34 million, Hanna Holdings at $8.25 million, HomeServices of America at $30 million and Douglas Elliman at $2.04 million. The parties were originally named as defendants in the Batton 1 and 2, Cwynar, Davis and Lutz lawsuits.
In an order, the judge listed five topics for further information. They include whether earlier home seller settlements are an appropriate benchmark for the buyer settlements, given that those agreements resolved both buyer and seller claims, and how each settling defendant's financial ability to pay and transaction volume factored into its amount.
The court also asked what plaintiffs could realistically expect to recover at trial, for examples of benchmarks from other indirect purchaser class actions, and for an estimate of how much individual claimants and class members would receive. Briefs are due December 14, 2026.
The opt-in settlements, which total more than $120 million, gained preliminary approval in late May. At the hearing the court rejected claims they resulted from a "reverse auction," finding the proposed opt-in settlements were "fair, reasonable and adequate" and that the opt-in agreements compensate indirect purchaser claims at almost the same rate as the claims previously resolved by the Burnett, Gibson, Keel and Hooper settlements.
