Key facts
- The Aspect plane has flown more than 80 emergency missions over its 25-year history, an average of more than three a year.
- Three former program insiders told Floodlight the program has deteriorated to the point where it is now of little use.
- The EPA said the plane's chemical sensors are wearing out and expects replacements to be working by mid-2027.
- The EPA bypassed competitive bidding to award Canadian company Telops a $1.7 million contract for replacement sensors, procurement documents show.
- Former Aspect scientist Robert Kroutil said a hand analysis of Smitty's flight data found high toluene levels that could have put nearby communities at risk.
- The EPA did not respond to Floodlight's questions about the program's decline, emergency responses or replacement sensors.
The EPA's Aspect plane, a single-engine Cessna designed to fly over chemical emergencies and identify pollutants in the air, responded to just seven emergencies since early 2021, according to a report published November 16, 2026 by the non-profit newsroom Floodlight. Three former program insiders told Floodlight the program has deteriorated to the point where it is now of little use.
The plane stayed on the ground during an ammonia leak outside a hotel in Weatherford, Oklahoma, that injured 74 people in November 2025, a March fire at a Valero refinery in Port Arthur, Texas, and blasts at a Toledo, Ohio, recycling plant that killed two workers in August, the report said. It was one of at least 80 chemical emergencies in 2026 that the plane did not respond to, Floodlight reported.
After the September 11, 2001, attacks, the Department of Defense transferred its airborne chemical sensing program to the EPA for civilian emergencies. Over its 25-year history the plane has flown more than 80 emergency missions, an average of more than three a year. During a 2019 EPA reorganization, the agency told Aspect staff to relocate to Texas, where the plane was based, or face termination, an internal EPA memo shows. Thomas retired rather than uproot his family and other key staff left.
In June, the EPA inspector general found the plane could no longer identify chemicals within minutes as designed; data had to be analyzed by hand, a process taking about a week. The EPA said the plane's chemical sensors are wearing out and expects replacements to be working by mid-2027. The agency bypassed competitive bidding to award Telops, a Canadian company, a $1.7 million contract for replacement sensors, procurement documents show, with integration expected by early to mid-2027.
Thomas, Kroutil and Turville told Floodlight the agency is fixing the wrong problem, saying the old sensors still work but the EPA lost the expertise and initiative that made the program effective. Telops parent company Exosens told Floodlight the systems use fundamentally different technologies and can identify hundreds of chemicals with additional analysis. Chris Manning, an independent spectrometer expert, said the new sensors could complement the old ones but would be a poor replacement, being slower, less sensitive and less suited to moving targets.
At Smitty's Supply in Roseland, Louisiana, where an explosion on August 22, 2025, started a fire that burned for two weeks, the EPA posted findings of ozone and three other air pollutants at levels far below those expected to cause health effects. Kroutil said a later hand analysis of raw flight data identified high concentrations of toluene, a neurotoxicant, and the carcinogens trichloroethylene and naphthalene, and concluded toluene levels could have put nearby communities at risk. The EPA did not respond to Floodlight's questions about the program's decline, emergency responses or replacement sensors.