Key facts
- Compass said it will seek to dismiss the seven MLSs' consolidated declaratory judgment action in New York.
- Alternatively, Compass asked the court to sever each MLS's claims and transfer them to the district where its own suit is pending.
- The MLSs are seeking declarations that their rules comply with Section 1 of the Sherman Act and state antitrust statutes.
- The MLSs said Compass's 15-case strategy across 11 districts invites inconsistent outcomes and inefficiencies.
- The MLSs argue their choice of Compass's home forum deserves deference because Compass executives and documents are in New York.
Compass International Holdings and seven multiple listing services are asking a federal judge in New York to decide whether their antitrust dispute over MLS cooperation and listing submission rules should proceed there. The parties filed dueling letters in November 2026 laying out competing arguments on forum shopping, efficiency and control over nationwide litigation.
In a November 13 letter to US District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil, Compass said it will seek to dismiss a consolidated declaratory judgment action filed by seven MLSs headquartered in Arizona, California, Colorado and North Carolina, or alternatively to sever and transfer each MLS's claims to the district where Compass has brought its own antitrust case against that MLS. The suit was filed in the Southern District of New York by Arizona Regional MLS, OneKey MLS, MLSListings, Bridge MLS, Canopy MLS, Recolorado, Hive MLS and Doorify MLS after Compass sent letters to MLSs across the country in September demanding they stop fining agents for publicly marketing office exclusive listings.
The MLSs are seeking declarations that their rules comply with Section 1 of the Sherman Act and state antitrust statutes, and an injunction preventing Compass from bringing or pursuing any claim against them over those rules, according to the amended complaint. Compass told the court the consolidated suit is an improper anticipatory filing under the Declaratory Judgment Act, citing precedent that courts may decline jurisdiction when declaratory relief is used for procedural fencing. The company pointed to its September demand letters, the sue-by deadlines it set and a series of extensions it granted as a good-faith attempt to resolve the dispute short of litigation.
Compass said counsel for ARMLS, Doorify MLS and Hive MLS requested a draft release and then sought additional time, citing illness and scheduling constraints, before filing the New York suit without substantively responding to the demands. Other MLSs, including MLSListings, BridgeMLS, REcolorado and Canopy MLS, also requested extensions, Compass said. Compass alleges the MLSs used those extensions to prepare the New York filing and then sued the day after certain extended deadlines expired. Compass said it has since filed home-district actions against each MLS in its own federal district, along with additional suits against other MLSs.
As an alternative to dismissal, Compass asked the court to sever each MLS's claims and transfer them to the districts where its separate antitrust suits are pending: Arizona, Northern California, Colorado and the Western and Eastern Districts of North Carolina. Compass said the MLSs themselves allege they act independently, operate in distinct regional markets, have different governing boards and maintain non-identical rules, and that a shared adversary and a similar demand letter do not make their policies a single transaction or occurrence.
In a response letter sent on November 18, counsel for the MLS plaintiffs urged the court to keep the case and deny Compass's anticipated motions. The MLSs argue the New York suit is a textbook use of the Declaratory Judgment Act and that Compass, from its New York headquarters, orchestrated a nationwide campaign against cooperation rules that should be resolved in a single forum. The MLSs characterize Compass's pre-suit communications differently, saying the company presented only two options: abandon their cooperation rules entirely in exchange for what they describe as a toothless release that left them under a perpetual threat of future litigation, or face antitrust lawsuits without clarity as to timing or venue.
The MLSs also dispute Compass's forum-shopping argument, emphasizing that they sued the brokerage in its home district and in the same court where Compass chose to litigate a separate cooperation-rule case against Zillow. They say Compass's 15-case strategy across 11 districts invites inconsistent outcomes and massive inefficiencies. The MLS plaintiffs also oppose severance, transfer and stay, arguing their joinder meets federal procedure rules because each faces the same type of challenge from a single defendant over listing-submission rules that share common structure and legal issues. They say Compass cannot meet its burden to show by clear and convincing evidence that moving the case would serve the convenience of parties and witnesses and the interests of justice, and that their choice of Compass's home forum is entitled to substantial deference because Compass's executives and documents are in New York.
