Key facts
- Lamacchia Realty said it paid Chinatti Realty Group more than $350,000 in 75% to 85% referral fees on behalf of former Chinatti agents.
- Lamacchia Realty said it paid agents $113,443 to make them whole on commissions not paid by Chinatti for pending transactions.
- The plaintiffs claim Chinatti misclassified them as independent contractors despite exercising controls beyond normal broker supervision.
- Judge Lynn Rooney found Lisa Chinatti deliberately caused the Real Geeks CRM data to be destroyed and that plaintiffs suffered unfair prejudice.
- The court forwarded its ruling and concerns about recorded calls to the Massachusetts Attorney General's Criminal Bureau for review of potential wiretap violations.
- The court has not ruled on the plaintiffs' motion or on Chinatti's motions for summary judgment.
A lawsuit pending in Massachusetts Superior Court for Middlesex County claims that Chinatti Realty Group and its broker-owner Lisa Chinatti charged referral fees as high as 85% when agents who left the firm closed transactions with leads in its database, according to a HousingWire report published November 18, 2026. Lamacchia Realty, eight of its agents and its former sales manager Jason Posnick filed the suit in August 2024 and amended it in late February 2025. The plaintiffs claim the independent contractor agreements were unconscionable and that the fees have prevented the agents from earning a living in real estate.
Lamacchia Realty said it has paid Chinatti Realty Group more than $350,000 in 75% to 85% referral fees on behalf of former Chinatti agents. The brokerage also said it paid agents $113,443 to make them whole on commissions not paid to them by Chinatti for pending transactions that closed after they departed. The agents further claim Chinatti misclassified them as independent contractors despite exercising controls beyond normal broker supervision.
During discovery, the court learned that Chinatti Realty Group switched customer relationship management software from Real Geeks to Zillow's Follow Up Boss in December 2024 and that some records could not be transferred. In a mid-September ruling, Judge Lynn Rooney found that Lisa Chinatti knew the Real Geeks data was relevant to the dispute from the November 2022 demand letter and did nothing to preserve it, deliberately causing the CRM to be destroyed. Rooney found the plaintiffs suffered unfair prejudice and said that at a minimum they would be entitled to a jury instruction that the missing evidence would have been unfavorable to the defendants.
