Key facts
- A Reuters review of more than 300 Chinese papers, patents, disclosures, recruitment notices and government documents found distillation has moved into mainstream industrial use.
- US Commerce Department officials raised concerns with Chinese regulators in Chengdu in July, three people familiar with the discussions said.
- Chinese officials defended distillation as standard practice and said they were open to acting where it constituted IP theft, a US official said.
- A January policy package from eight Chinese agencies includes guidance supporting model training, fine-tuning and distillation for industrial applications.
- OpenAI's terms restrict using its output to develop competing models, subject to exceptions; Anthropic similarly restricts training competing systems without permission.
- A US official said Washington sees industrial-scale distillation as the main reason Chinese AI models have narrowed the gap with American rivals.
Chinese entities are adopting increasingly sophisticated ways to use output from leading American AI models to train domestic rivals, according to a Reuters review of more than 300 Chinese academic papers, patents, corporate disclosures, recruitment notices and government documents published on November 17. The review found the practice, known as distillation, has expanded beyond academic experiments into mainstream industrial use in China.
The records describe Chinese researchers using US models to produce answers to questions, build computer code and find solutions to difficult problems, with Chinese companies then developing software to automate the process and specialist workers preparing material for training smaller domestic models. The documents also show Beijing is encouraging distillation to make AI cheaper and easier to deploy across China's manufacturing sector.
Distillation is not illegal and is prevalent elsewhere. It cannot reproduce a leading model's full capabilities or remove the need for advanced computing power, but it can help developers preserve selected skills in smaller systems that cost less to operate. Washington said on Monday it would further restrict China's access to advanced chips from companies like Nvidia.
US authorities publicly accused Chinese companies in September of aggressive, targeted distillation of American AI models on an industrial scale. At meetings in Chengdu in July, US Commerce Department officials raised concerns with Chinese regulators about developers collecting output from leading American AI models, warning some activities could amount to intellectual-property theft, three people familiar with the discussions said. Chinese officials defended distillation as a standard AI-development technique and said they were open to acting where the conduct constituted IP theft, but made no concrete commitments, according to a US official familiar with the previously unreported exchange. The US Commerce Department and China's Cyberspace Administration did not respond to requests for comment.
In a November 2024 paper, Shanghai Jiao Tong University researchers described selecting about 5,000 answers from OpenAI's o1 model, translating them using GPT-4o mini and assembling 10,750 bilingual training examples to further train Alibaba's Qwen2.5-72B model. They cautioned that excessive reliance on distillation could stifle original innovation. Alibaba researchers described a more systematic approach in an April 2025 paper, using OpenAI's GPT-4 and GPT-4o to generate training material in languages other than Chinese before training smaller Qwen models. In a February 2026 paper, researchers from Shanghai Jiao Tong University and Meituan described using GPT-4o to generate plans for coordinating AI agents on programming problems. Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Alibaba and Meituan did not respond to requests for comment.
OpenAI's terms restrict using its output to develop competing models, subject to exceptions, while Anthropic similarly restricts training competing systems without permission. A US official familiar with the July Chengdu discussions said Washington believes industrial-scale distillation is the main reason Chinese AI models have narrowed the gap with American rivals. Two people familiar with Chinese developers' operations disputed that assessment, saying distillation was only one factor alongside advances in engineering, algorithms, data and model design.
A national AI+Manufacturing policy package published by eight Chinese government agencies in January includes guidance supporting model training, fine-tuning and distillation for industrial applications. Shanghai and Shenzhen have also encouraged techniques to reduce computing requirements. Chinese AI developers have in recent months asked Beijing's industry regulator for guidance on the boundaries between ordinary use of foreign models and organised collection of output for training, according to one person familiar with the discussions. The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology did not respond to a request for comment.