Key facts
- Federal circuit court justice Karl Blake found the glasses incident was on any objective view a serious incident.
- Blake found Martins Silva was not dismissed for making complaints but because he wore smartglasses at the terminal.
- Origin Energy asked that the employee be removed from work as soon as possible, citing poor attitude, the judgment said.
- Martins Silva had conceded in cross examination that he knew at the time he had done the wrong thing, the judgment stated.
- He wrote to his employer that his judgment had been affected by unresolved trauma from a truck fire in March 2025.
Toll Transport fired LPG tanker driver Ricardo Martins Silva on July 18, 2025, after he used smartglasses to take photographs at the Long Island Point terminal in Hastings, Victoria, a federal circuit court judgment handed down last week stated. He had been with the company eight months, driving a loaded LPG tanker for Origin Energy from the terminal for onward delivery.
The judgment stated that on June 17, 2025, Martins Silva raised concerns about a truck allocated to him, telling superiors it vibrated too much and jumped excessively. He was advised to take a different truck, and at the terminal took photographs with his smartglasses and sent them to a superior with a message saying he was taking the truck back to Dandenong and leaving.
An Esso worker at the terminal told Toll that any use of electrical equipment on-site was intrinsically unsafe because of the risk of an explosion caused by electrical spark. Martins Silva was prevented from taking on additional work until an investigation was completed, and Origin Energy later asked that he be removed as soon as possible, saying his attitude was poor and that not doing planned deliveries because he was tired and stressed was not acceptable, the judgment read.
Martins Silva sent emails between June 17 and June 19 raising concerns about his role, truck allocations and safety issues, and on June 20 submitted a complaint about his employment including safety and the impact of working conditions on his health. He was advised he was stood down on June 22, and at a June 24 meeting Toll raised the glasses incident, telling him it was a critical safety breach and that it had begun an investigation.
By June 30 Toll decided he should be suspended, citing among other reasons the seriousness of the glasses incident. On July 9 he was told the photograph breached Toll's code of practice and his contract, and his employment was terminated on July 18.
Martins Silva claimed the action breached the Fair Work Act, arguing Toll acted because of complaints he had made. Justice Karl Blake found the glasses incident was on any objective view a serious incident, that Martins Silva had sought to mitigate the risk by covering his smartglasses with safety glasses, and that he was not dismissed for making complaints but because he wore the smartglasses at the terminal. The application was dismissed.
The case is the first reported in Australia of a worker dismissed for using smartglasses in a workplace. Since the arrival of Meta's Ray-Bans and cheaper alternatives such as the Kmart Anko brand, councils across Australia have banned the glasses from some public spaces including gyms and pools, and the federal government is considering bans in government offices.