Key facts
- The ALRC recommended keeping the ban on commercial surrogacy while increasing surrogate compensation.
- Compensation would cover medical costs, loss of earnings including superannuation, birth support and other pregnancy costs.
- The report recommends licensed surrogacy support organizations to help intended parents connect with surrogates.
- Intended parents using overseas arrangements would have to register, receive official guidance and obtain legal advice in both countries.
- Failing those obligations could result in a civil penalty, principal legal officer Jacinth Pathmanathan said.
- ALRC president Justice Mordy Bromberg said current laws drive Australians to pursue overseas surrogacy arrangements.
The Australian Law Reform Commission tabled 47 recommendations on Tuesday evening aimed at making domestic surrogacy easier to access while safeguarding all parties. The report is now with the commonwealth attorney general for consideration.
The recommendations include licensed surrogacy support organizations to help intended parents connect with surrogates, greater compensation for surrogates and stronger safeguards around who the child's legal parents are. The commission recommended keeping the ban on commercial surrogacy but said surrogates should receive greater compensation to cover medical costs, loss of earnings including superannuation, birth support and other costs incurred by the pregnancy.
ALRC president Justice Mordy Bromberg said current laws fail to enable family formation through surrogacy or provide effective safeguards against exploitation and harm. He said the laws drive Australians to pursue overseas surrogacy arrangements, which can expose children, surrogates and intended parents to risk of harm and exploitation.
The review found inconsistent surrogacy laws and criminal sanctions are driving parents overseas and arrangements underground. The report said estimates suggest domestic gestational births more than tripled from 27 in 2014 to 84 in 2023, while overseas surrogacy rose from 246 births in 2015 to 375 in 2024, an increase of more than 40%.
ALRC principal legal officer Jacinth Pathmanathan said intended parents using overseas arrangements would need to register, receive official guidance and obtain legal advice in both Australia and the overseas country. They would also need to take reasonable steps to avoid arrangements that are unlawful in the overseas country, do not meet minimum Australian requirements or pose significant risk. Failing those obligations could result in a civil penalty, she said.