Key facts
- Bank capital rules in the EU and US are diverging, particularly concerning credit valuation adjustments (CVA) for counterparty credit risk.
- While many EU banks are opting for the simpler fallback approach (BA-CVA) for CVA capital charges, US banks are expected to predominantly adopt the more sophisticated standardized approach (SA-CVA).
- This divergence is driven by differing regulatory decisions, including the US plan to phase out internal models for credit risk and the proposed removal of the Collins Floor.
- EU banks found that the BA-CVA could offer lower capital and operational costs, especially when combined with existing internal models for counterparty credit risk.
- The EU's decision to retain exemptions for CVA capital charges on certain counterparty groups also impacted the attractiveness of SA-CVA in Europe.
- US banks are incentivized to invest in SA-CVA due to proposed rule changes that would make it a more significant factor in determining capital requirements.
Bank capital rules in the European Union and the United States are increasingly diverging, with the latest example being the capital charges for credit valuation adjustments (CVA), which measure risks from deteriorating derivatives counterparties.
Following reforms by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision in 2017, the standardized approach (SA-CVA) became the most sophisticated option, intended to reward banks for investments in risk measurement. However, many EU banks opted for the simpler fallback approach (BA-CVA) when the new rules took effect last year. This choice was often driven by the realization that BA-CVA, when combined with internal models for counterparty credit risk, could result in lower capital requirements and operational expenses compared to SA-CVA.
Further complicating the EU's adoption of SA-CVA was the decision to retain existing exemptions for CVA capital charges on exposures to corporates, sovereigns, and pension funds. These exemptions reduced the capital benefits of SA-CVA, particularly for uncollateralized trades with larger market risk exposures.
In contrast, US banks are anticipated to largely adopt the SA-CVA. This expectation is fueled by US regulators' plans to phase out internal models for credit risk, compelling banks to use the more punitive standardized approach (SA-CCR) within BA-CVA, making it less appealing. Additionally, proposed changes to remove the 'Collins Floor' in the US would ensure CVA always plays a role in capital requirements, incentivizing banks to invest in capital-efficient SA-CVA approaches.
This divergence highlights a growing gap in regulatory approaches between the US and EU, with US banks being pushed towards sophisticated CVA methods while EU banks are leaning towards simpler ones, partly due to regulatory choices and cost considerations. US regulators are still finalizing their Basel III implementation, with compliance not expected until 2028 at the earliest.