Key facts
- US intelligence reports claim Alice Huang had ties to China's Ministry of State Security; the claim remains unproven.
- Beijing's foreign ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said the US should stop fabricating espionage narratives to justify technological blockades.
- The new US rules target Chinese firms renting computing power in data centers in countries such as Malaysia, Thailand and Brazil.
- Democrat Ted Lieu told Politico the Trump administration had been 1,000% too deferential to Nvidia.
- A source familiar told The Hill that Nvidia's board is not considering returning Jensen Huang as CEO.
- Craig Singleton of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies told reporters he doubts Trump will raise the scandal with Xi.
US President Donald Trump is traveling to ASEAN and APEC meetings in the Philippines and China while allegations involving former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang hang over his talks with Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping. The BBC reported that US intelligence claims Alice Huang, a Chinese businesswoman linked to Huang, had ties to Beijing's Ministry of State Security, China's main civilian spy agency. The claim remains unproven.
Beijing's foreign ministry has described the spy claims as a smear against China. Spokesperson Mao Ning said last week the US should stop fabricating so-called espionage narratives to find pretexts for imposing technological blockades. The ministry also said the two countries had kept close communication regarding interactions between the two heads of state.
The Trump administration introduced new export restrictions on Chinese firms that access advanced US chips in third countries such as Malaysia, Thailand and Brazil, where they rent computing power in data centers abroad to train AI models. Some of those firms, including the one Alice Huang worked for, are also accused of smuggling chips to China, although they have denied this. Beijing called the new rules economic coercion on the eve of Trump arriving in Shenzhen.
Democrats, who will control Congress come January, have signaled they will take a harder line. Top Democrat Ted Lieu told Politico the Trump administration had been 1,000% too deferential to Nvidia, putting national security at risk, while fellow Democrat Zoe Lofgren suggested Congress would now be more likely to restrict sales of AI chips to China. The BBC said it had approached the White House for comment.
Trump said last week he would not raise the Huang matter with Xi but expected Xi to ask about it, and said on Monday he would not mind if Huang were reinstated as Nvidia's CEO. A source familiar told The Hill that Nvidia's board is not considering returning Huang as CEO. Craig Singleton of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies told reporters he doubts Trump will raise the scandal with Xi.
Analysts in China see echoes of a 2023 incident when a suspected surveillance balloon drifted over the US before an American fighter jet shot it down. Beijing insisted it was a civilian meteorological airship that had strayed off course. A planned trip by then US Secretary of State Antony Blinken was canceled and communication between the two governments deteriorated sharply. The state media outlet Global Times this week drew a direct comparison with the Nvidia scandal, asking whether someone behind the scenes was pushing an agenda and stirring up confrontation.
Both leaders have incentives to keep talking. China's economy remains under pressure and is increasingly reliant on exports, and Xi needs trade to keep flowing ahead of replacing the current trade truce due to expire in January. Trump has repeatedly touted his close relationship with Xi and argued that maintaining dialogue is essential to managing competition between the two powers. Beijing has also chosen Shenzhen, home to some of China's biggest tech companies, as a showcase for its ambitions in AI and advanced manufacturing.
Beijing has options for retaliation, including its dominance of key rare earth minerals. China processes much of the world's supply of materials used in everything from electric vehicles and smartphones to military equipment.
