Key facts
- The Supreme Court declined to halt an $800-a-day fine for Catherine Herridge.
- Herridge is in civil contempt for refusing to reveal her sources.
- The fine stems from a lawsuit by scientist Yanping Chen alleging Privacy Act violations.
- A judge ruled Chen's need to identify the source outweighed Herridge's First Amendment arguments.
- Fox News expressed disappointment and vowed to continue defending journalistic source confidentiality.
The Supreme Court on Thursday declined to intervene in a case where former Fox News reporter Catherine Herridge is being fined $800 per day for refusing to reveal her confidential sources. The fine is part of a civil contempt ruling stemming from a lawsuit filed by scientist Yanping Chen, who was investigated by the FBI but never charged.
Chen sued the FBI and the Justice Department in 2018, alleging violations of the Privacy Act due to the public disclosure of private information without her consent. Her lawsuit stated that the leaks upended her personal and professional life. A judge ordered Herridge to disclose her sources in a deposition, ruling that Chen's need for the information in her lawsuit outweighed the reporter's right to protect her sources. Herridge refused to answer questions about her sources during her deposition, leading to the contempt finding and the imposition of the daily fine, which was upheld by an appeals court panel.
Fox News stated that protecting the confidentiality of journalistic sourcing is fundamental to a free and functioning democracy and that they will be reviewing their options to further fight this injustice.