Key facts
- South Korea's foreign ministry said it postponed the visit during the previously agreed November 23 to December 4 period.
- The ministry said the working group's terms of reference for country visits are not legally binding on South Korea.
- The working group said freedom of inquiry, including unannounced visits to places of deprivation of liberty, is required for its mandate.
- The working group said it remained ready to continue consultations with South Korea to enable a visit.
- The working group has never conducted an official country visit to South Korea since its establishment in 1991.
South Korea's foreign ministry said on November 20 that it had postponed a planned visit by the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, after the two sides disagreed over whether the experts could make unannounced visits to prisons and other detention facilities.
The government accepted the working group's request to visit in January and held consultations with the group and relevant domestic agencies from July through November, according to the ministry. The working group maintained that unannounced visits were essential to its country visits, while South Korean authorities concluded after reviewing relevant laws that they may not agree to such inspections.
"Accordingly, the government decided to postpone the visit during the previously agreed period, taking into account the time needed for further consultations," the ministry said in a notice to reporters. It added that it was discussing ways to host the group in a manner consistent with domestic laws and based on mutual respect and agreement.
The ministry also said the working group's terms of reference for country visits, which the group cited as the basis for its request, are not legally binding on South Korea and serve only as a reference document. The government proposed that the group give advance notice of sites it planned to visit, but the working group rejected the proposal, citing its rules on unannounced visits, according to the report.
The working group said on November 19 that it regretted Seoul's decision not to proceed. "The effectiveness and independence of the mandate require guarantees of freedom of inquiry, including the ability to conduct unannounced visits to places of deprivation of liberty," it said in a press release. The group said it remained ready to continue consultations with South Korea.
The working group is one of 59 special procedures of the UN Human Rights Council and reports on cases of arbitrary detention. It typically visits one or two countries each year and has never conducted an official country visit to South Korea since its establishment in 1991. South Korea is serving as a member of the Human Rights Council for the 2025-2027 term. Some civic groups expressed concern that the postponement could affect the country's credibility on its human rights commitments, according to the report.