Key facts
- Signal said the new screenshot blocks are switched on by default, with pop-ups offering users the option to disable them.
- Signal called its new protections incomplete and said it could not reliably offer such protections on Apple's macOS.
- Signal singled out Apple's Siri AI and Google's Gemini Intelligence as particularly worrisome because they are built into operating systems.
- Meta said agents need to see and interact with computers to work on users' behalf, and that Muse accesses other apps only via permissions users explicitly grant.
- Signal is owned by a non-profit foundation and offers end-to-end encryption, meaning it cannot read conversations on its app.
Encrypted messaging service Signal said on November 20 that it would restrict screenshots to stop AI agents from reading private chats on phones, warning that the tech industry's push to embed AI in consumer devices was eroding its ability to guarantee privacy.
Signal, which privacy advocates widely regard as a leader in secure messaging, called its new protections incomplete and urged operating system providers Apple, Alphabet's Google and Microsoft to give app developers more concrete ways to block the agents from accessing sensitive data. It also asked those companies to provide more information about how their agents function, so developers can assess what data the bots access and adjust their systems.
Signal identified AI capabilities built directly into operating systems, such as Apple's Siri AI and Google's Gemini Intelligence, as particularly worrisome because of how deeply they are integrated into people's devices. "Right now, these agentic AI integrations are changing this environment in a way that's making it increasingly hostile to privacy. This is an existential threat to Signal, and our ability to responsibly uphold our mission," Signal said in a blog post provided to Reuters ahead of its release on Signal's website.
To prevent agents from scanning Signal messages, the service is introducing new settings blocking screenshot access on phones and switching those restrictions on by default. Users will receive pop-up windows offering options to disable the blocks when Signal detects screenshot attempts or efforts by an AI assistant to access the screen, depending on the device. Signal similarly blocked Microsoft's Recall AI from taking screenshots on Windows in 2025, and said it was unable to reliably offer such protections on Apple's macOS.
Agents that can take actions on behalf of users are billed as the next big wave of AI technology, capable of surfacing information across apps and executing tasks such as answering emails, booking appointments and making online purchases without direct instructions. That reach can get around protections apps like Signal build for themselves. Reuters reported earlier this week that Meta's Muse agent was able to bypass its own official Connector tool to access Signal messages on both an Apple computer and a phone using Google's Android system, using broad operating system-level permissions granted during setup.
On Apple's macOS, Muse used a combination of the computer's accessibility and screenshot tools, repurposing settings Apple offers for people with disabilities to navigate to Signal, take screenshots of chats, extract text from those pictures and reproduce the messages inside the Muse app. An operating system update from Apple this week effectively closed that specific pathway but introduced a new set of permissions aimed at agents that offers similar capabilities paired with additional user warnings.
Meta said in response to Reuters' reporting that agents need to see and interact with people's computers to work on their behalf, and that Muse can access other apps only via permissions users explicitly grant. Signal said developers should have straightforward ways of opting their apps out of such data processing by AI assistants entirely, specifically mentioning screen reading, notifications and other file system access.
The service, owned by a non-profit foundation, promises users a secure messaging experience by limiting the data it stores on its own servers, eschewing ads and offering end-to-end encryption, meaning it cannot access and read conversations conducted on its app. AI systems that scan people's screens can undermine those protections by pulling messages out of Signal's secure environment and into whatever other servers the agent is using, it said in the post.
