Key facts
- The bill would let MACH Energy raise output at Mount Pleasant in Muswellbrook by 32% to 16.5 million tonnes a year.
- Barrister Geoffrey Watson said Clause 17 gives the mining minister power to make, repeal or modify state laws for one mine owner.
- Elaine Johnson of Johnson Legal said the clause gives the resources minister unfetched power to change how any state law applies to the mine.
- The Minns government said the legislation is needed to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas.
- Coalition resources spokesperson Dave Layzell said the opposition would not oppose the legislation in any way.
- Independent MP Alex Greenwich said he intends to oppose the bill as a whole.
A New South Wales government bill to increase coal production at MACH Energy's Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook would give the resources minister powers that create a serious corruption risk, barrister and anti-corruption campaigner Geoffrey Watson said in a legal analysis. The state parliament is due to debate the legislation on November 17, with the lower house expected to consider it first and the upper house later in the week.
The bill would allow MACH Energy to raise output at the Hunter Valley mine by 32% to 16.5 million tonnes a year. The Minns government announced the bill after the high court ruled that an expansion of the mine was invalidly approved. The government has said the legislation is necessary to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas.
Watson, a director of the Centre for Public Integrity and Grata Fund and a former counsel assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption, said Clause 17 explicitly places wide powers to make, repeal or modify state laws in the hands of one person, the mining minister, for a single coal mine owner. He said the concentration of this kind of power creates a serious corruption risk and that the risk is heightened because the bill was created for a single private company. He said he imputed no bad faith to the current mining minister.
Elaine Johnson, director of Johnson Legal, which represented the Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group in the high court proceedings, raised similar concerns in a separate legal opinion. She said Clause 17 gives the resources minister of the day unfetched power to change the application of any state law to the mine and could affect laws regulating noise, dust and worker safety.
A spokesperson for resources minister Courtney Houssos said the government had been clear that the purpose of the bill was to protect all permanent workers at Mount Pleasant and that the bill had been presented transparently to parliament. The spokesperson said any proposed regulation would be submitted to the Executive Council for approval and published and subject to disallowance in the usual manner, and that Henry VIII provisions had been routinely used in legislation for decades.
Coalition resources spokesperson and Nationals MP for Upper Hunter Dave Layzell said the opposition would not oppose Labor's legislation in any way. He said the Coalition would follow advice on the bill from the parliament's legislation review committee, expected on November 17. Greens climate spokesperson Sue Higginson said it was the broadest Henry VIII clause she had seen during the current parliament and the party would seek to remove it or limit its scope. Independent MP Alex Greenwich, who intends to oppose the bill as a whole, said the provision was dangerously broad and quite unprecedented.