Key facts
- Baldwin's bill would end permanent normal trade relations a year after enactment, moving Chinese imports to higher regular tariff rates.
- The US International Trade Commission said in August that revoking the status would raise trade-weighted average tariffs by 35.2 percentage points.
- Two ITC commissioners, one Republican and one Democrat, disputed the finding that ending PNTR would raise costs.
- Trump meets Xi in Shenzhen this week to discuss a trade truce that expires in January.
- Trump could veto the bill if it passes, the report said.
US Democratic Senator Tammy Baldwin introduced legislation on Tuesday to revoke China's normal trade status and its favorable tariff treatment, days before US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping are due to meet for a third time this year to discuss a trade truce.
The bill argues Beijing failed to uphold the principles of fair trade. It would set a deadline to end the permanent normal trade relations in effect since 2002, one year after the legislation is enacted, and would shift Chinese imports to higher regular US tariff rates under the Harmonized Tariff Schedule.
Existing US Most Favored Nation tariff rates for China and other countries average about 2.5%, according to the report. Trump has imposed punitive duties on Chinese imports, about 25% during his first term and up to 20% during his second term under a trade truce with Beijing.
The bill would also direct the US Trade Representative's office to issue a report with the Commerce Department, the US International Trade Commission and other bodies on trade and economic challenges posed by China.
Lawmakers have repeatedly sought to revoke China's special treatment in recent years, but the bills failed because of competing economic priorities, legislative bottlenecks and shifting trade dynamics, with Republicans not challenging Trump's tariff pressure. The report says anti-China sentiment in Congress is growing, particularly among Democrats who won control of both the Senate and House of Representatives in elections this month. Trump, who meets Xi in Shenzhen this week, could still veto the bill if it passes.
"We need to reset our trade relationship with China, be honest that they have undercut us at every turn, and put the focus back where it matters, prioritizing American workers, manufacturers and families," Baldwin said. She voted against the change in China's tariff treatment in 2000 while serving in the House of Representatives.
Baldwin said in a statement that the US had "rolled out the red carpet for China" for two decades while Beijing engaged in market manipulation, intellectual property theft and other unfair trade practices. She noted that the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission, an independent, bipartisan legislative agency, also recommended revoking China's PNTR status in November 2024.
Revoking China's current trade status would raise the price of Chinese imports, especially manufactured goods, and in the long run raise US consumer prices by 0.7% and reduce US economic output by 0.2%, the US International Trade Commission said in a 319-page report released in August. The ITC concluded that revoking PNTR would raise trade-weighted average tariffs by 35.2 percentage points. Two ITC commissioners, a Republican and a Democrat, challenged the notion that ending PNTR would raise costs, arguing the analysis failed to account for economic harm caused by granting it.
Trump, who ordered a review of China's trade status when he took office in January 2025, and Xi are expected to discuss a trade-war truce that will expire in January. China's foreign ministry has accused the US of "economic coercion" over its latest restrictions on Chinese access to advanced chips.
