Key facts
- The Alaska Supreme Court ruled a man with the same name and party as U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan can appear on the August primary ballot.
- The court reversed a decision by the Division of Elections that had removed the challenger.
- The challenger's candidacy was initially deemed not filed in good faith and intended to confuse voters.
- A state court judge had previously found the election division abused its discretion.
- The Division of Elections will now determine how the challenger is listed on the ballot.
The Alaska Supreme Court has ruled that a man sharing the name and Republican party affiliation of U.S. Senator Dan Sullivan is eligible to appear on the August primary ballot. The decision on Monday affirmed a previous ruling by state court Judge Thomas Matthews, who found that the Division of Elections had abused its discretion in removing the challenger.
The Division of Elections, through its director Carol Beecher, had initially decided on June 15 that the challenger's candidacy was not filed in good faith and was intended to confuse voters. However, Judge Matthews stated that Beecher's decision was not based on constitutional requirements for serving in the Senate or on state laws.
The dispute began when the challenger filed his candidacy approximately a month ago, sparking accusations from Senator Sullivan and his allies that the challenger was a sham candidate aiming to disrupt the election. Republicans have accused the challenger of being a Democratic plant meant to siphon votes and have filed complaints to state and federal agencies. The campaign of Dan J. Sullivan, who recently changed his registration to Republican, stated he is running due to unhappiness with the incumbent's record and a desire for change.
Republican fears are amplified by Alaska’s ranked-choice primary system, which allows the top four vote-getters to advance to the general election. The two Sullivans could end up on the general election ballot together, potentially drawing votes from each other and boosting the prospects of Democratic candidate Mary Peltola. One Nation, a nonprofit aligned with the GOP super PAC Senate Leadership Fund, is already running ads to help voters differentiate between the two Sullivans. Peltola’s campaign and other Democratic campaign arms have denied involvement in the newcomer’s bid.
Alaska’s elections division, overseen by the state’s GOP lieutenant governor Nancy Dahlstrom, initially struck Dan J. Sullivan from the ballot. That decision was overturned by Judge Matthews and fast-tracked through the Alaska Supreme Court. The court remanded the case for the Division of Elections to determine how the challenger shall be listed as a candidate within existing ballot design law.