All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
Story archiveAll categories
← All Stories

EFL criticizes PFA legal challenge over new cost controls

Created at 11 Aug · 10:56 AM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

The English Football League expressed concern and disappointment over the PFA's legal action to block new cost controls in League One, stating that financial sustainability and player protection are intertwined and reforms are necessary for club stability.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

£7.3maverage loss per League One club last season
£8.3maverage owner funding per League One club last season

Who's Involved

English Football League
criticized PFA legal challenge over cost controls
PFA
taking legal action against cost controls
Trevor Birch
EFL chief executive
EFL criticizes PFA legal challenge over new cost controls

↳ Why This Matters

The legal challenge by the PFA threatens the EFL's efforts to implement financial controls aimed at ensuring club sustainability, potentially impacting player earnings and the long-term health of the leagues below the Premier League.

Key facts

  • The English Football League (EFL) is concerned and disappointed by the PFA's legal challenge.
  • The PFA is opposing the Squad Cost Management Protocol, arguing it could harm players' earning potential.
  • EFL chief executive Trevor Birch stated that financial sustainability and player protection are linked.
  • The EFL noted that League One clubs averaged a loss of £7.3m and owner funding of £8.3m last season.
  • These figures represent more than a threefold increase since the 2021-22 season.

The English Football League (EFL) has expressed significant concern and disappointment regarding the Professional Footballers' Association's (PFA) decision to pursue legal action against new cost control measures for League One clubs. The PFA is opposing the Squad Cost Management Protocol, arguing that it could negatively impact players' earning potential, echoing a previous successful challenge in 2021 against a similar rule perceived as a de facto salary cap.

EFL chief executive Trevor Birch emphasized that financial sustainability and player protection are not conflicting goals but rather go hand in hand. He stated that the reforms are intended to foster greater club sustainability, which in turn ensures clubs are better positioned to honor contracts, pay wages promptly, invest in facilities, and provide long-term opportunities for players. Birch warned that increasing losses and reliance on owner funding pose risks to everyone involved in the game.

Birch highlighted the escalating financial challenges in the third tier, noting that last season, League One clubs averaged a loss of £7.3 million with owner funding at £8.3 million, figures that have more than tripled since the 2021-22 season. He stressed the need for rules that reflect the distinct financial realities faced by League One and League Two clubs, enabling responsible competition and planning.

This dispute arises as the EFL is also in discussions with the Premier League regarding a new financial redistribution deal. The newly operational Independent Football Regulator has the authority to intervene and mandate a resolution if the two leagues fail to reach an agreement.

Frequently asked questions

The PFA is opposing the Squad Cost Management Protocol, which aims to control spending by clubs in League One.

The PFA believes the protocol could damage players' earning potential and previously succeeded in blocking a similar rule in 2021.

The EFL argues the rules are necessary for financial sustainability, ensuring clubs can honor contracts and operate responsibly.

The EFL cited that last season, League One clubs averaged losses of £7.3 million, with owner funding at £8.3 million, a threefold increase since 2021-22.

What Happens Next

01The Independent Football Regulator may step in to mandate a financial redistribution deal if the Premier League and EFL do not agree.
02Further legal proceedings between the EFL and PFA are possible.

Get the newsletter.

Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

Cadence

How It Developed

The EFL criticized the PFA's legal challenge against new cost controls in League One.
The PFA opposes the Squad Cost Management Protocol, citing potential damage to players' earning potential.
EFL chief executive Trevor Birch stated that reforms are designed to make clubs more sustainable.
Birch highlighted that League One and League Two clubs operate in a different financial environment requiring tailored rules.
The EFL cited a significant increase in losses and owner funding for League One clubs since 2021-22.
The EFL is also considering a new financial redistribution deal with the Premier League.

Sources

T1
English Football League ‘concerned and disappointed’ at PFA legal challengeCity AM

Related Stories

Shareholder pushback drives up London takeover bids
11 Aug · 4:06 AM
Imperial Brands to cut thousands of jobs in U.S. and Europe
10 Aug · 2:59 PM
Lufthansa, German pilots' union agree process to resolve labour disputes
11 Aug · 8:06 AM
Fifa president Infantino faces calls to quit over World Cup sell-off plan
10 Aug · 1:11 PM
Smithfield Foods Cuts Annual Forecasts Amid Consumer Spending Squeeze
11 Aug · 9:48 AM