Idaho abortion ban unconstitutional for health exceptions, US judge rules | PiQ Markets
updating
2 storiesUS Politics & Policy
Idaho abortion ban unconstitutional for health exceptions, US judge rules
window 24h
IN SHORT
A U.S. judge has ruled Idaho's near-total abortion ban unconstitutional, finding it violates the 14th Amendment by not allowing exceptions for broader health risks beyond life-saving measures. This decision blocks the enforcement of laws that prohibit abortion care for serious medical conditions, including those impacting mental health. Separately, a U.S. federal appeals court has revived a Justice Department subpoena for records from QueerDoc, a provider of gender-affirming care for minors, overturning a lower court's decision that had blocked the subpoena due to bad faith.
✉Newsletter
PiQ Daily
Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.
Who's Involved
U.S. judge
ruled Idaho's near-total abortion ban unconstitutional
Idaho
state with a near-total abortion ban
14th Amendment
U.S. Constitutional amendment cited in ruling against abortion ban
U.S. federal appeals court
revived Justice Department subpoena for gender-affirming care provider
Justice Department
issued subpoena for gender-affirming care provider records
QueerDoc
provider of gender-affirming care for minors
1 / 2
Key facts
A U.S. judge ruled Idaho's near-total abortion ban unconstitutional.
The judge found the ban violates the 14th Amendment.
The ban did not allow abortions for broader health risks beyond life-saving measures.
The ruling blocks enforcement of laws prohibiting abortion care for serious medical conditions.
Mental health risks were included as a condition for which abortion care is prohibited under the ban.
A U.S. federal appeals court revived a Justice Department subpoena for records from QueerDoc.
QueerDoc is a provider of gender-affirming care for minors.
The appeals court overturned a lower court's decision that had blocked the subpoena.
The lower court had found the subpoena was issued in bad faith.
A U.S. judge has declared Idaho's near-total abortion ban unconstitutional, asserting that it violates the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The judge's ruling specifically addresses the lack of sufficient exceptions for abortions sought due to broader health risks, extending beyond only life-saving measures. Consequently, the enforcement of Idaho laws that prohibit abortion care for serious medical conditions, including those that pose risks to mental health, is now blocked.
In a separate development, a U.S. federal appeals court has reinstated a Justice Department subpoena directed at QueerDoc, a provider of gender-affirming care for minors. This appellate court ruling overturns a previous decision by a lower court, which had initially blocked the subpoena. The lower court had found that the subpoena was issued in bad faith. The appeals court's decision allows the Justice Department to proceed with obtaining the requested records from QueerDoc.
↳ Why This Matters
A U.S. judge has declared Idaho's near-total abortion ban unconstitutional, asserting that it violates the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The judge's ruling specifically addresses the lack of sufficient exceptions for abortions sought due to broader health risks, extending beyond only life-saving measures. Consequently, the enforcement of Idaho laws that prohibit abortion care for serious medical conditions, including those that pose risks to mental health, is now blocked.
Frequently asked questions
The "Defense of Life Act" and the "Fetal Heartbeat Act" were challenged.
The judge stated the laws violate the due process and equal protection clauses of the 14th Amendment.
Physicians can face up to five years in prison and lose their medical license.
The ruling blocks prosecution for abortions performed to protect a pregnant person's health or prevent self-harm, but the state plans to appeal.
What Happens Next
01Idaho's Attorney General plans to appeal the federal judge's ruling.
02Idaho voters will decide on a ballot initiative to roll back the state's abortion ban this fall.
Get the newsletter.
Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.