Key facts
- A US appeals court heard arguments on a contempt probe into Trump administration officials for alleged violation of a deportation flight order.
- The Justice Department argued the contempt probe initiated by US District Judge James Boasberg was unlawful, unnecessary, and futile.
- Some judges on the appeals court expressed skepticism about the Justice Department's arguments.
- The dispute arose from a lawsuit brought by the ACLU on behalf of Venezuelan men deported under the Alien Enemies Act.
- US District Judge James Boasberg concluded last year that the administration appeared to have acted in bad faith regarding deportation flights.
- The ACLU argued that the district court judge had acted courageously and refused to allow the executive branch to disregard the judiciary.
A US appeals court is considering whether to terminate a judge's inquiry into whether Trump administration officials willfully violated a judicial order directing them to stop deportation flights of Venezuelan immigrants to El Salvador. The Justice Department argued before the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit that the criminal contempt probe initiated by US District Judge James Boasberg was "unlawful, unnecessary, and futile," with an attorney stating the judge was "going beyond the judicial role."
However, some judges on the three-judge panel appeared skeptical of the Justice Department's arguments. Circuit Judge J. Michelle Childs noted that the judge was simply conducting "fact-finding to know what happened and know why there was a violation of the district court's order, oral and written." Circuit Judge Patricia Millett added that the district court "has to find out what happened and who was in the room providing the advice."
The dispute stems from a lawsuit brought by the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of Venezuelan men deported under the Alien Enemies Act. Judge Boasberg had previously concluded that the administration appeared to have acted "in bad faith" when it hastily arranged deportation flights while he was conducting emergency court proceedings to assess their legality. The ACLU lawyer, Lee Gelernt, argued that upholding the district court's actions was crucial to prevent the executive branch from disregarding the judiciary.
