All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
Story archiveAll categories
← All Stories

US, France clash at UN over rights chief's term extension

Created at 27 Jul · 7:17 PM4 sources↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

The U.S. delegation walked out of a UN Security Council meeting when France spoke, protesting comments that compared Washington's voting on human rights to that of authoritarian states. The row began after the U.S. voted against extending the UN rights chief's term.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

144states in favor of term extension
10states against term extension
13states abstained on term extension

Who's Involved

United States
walked out of UN Security Council meeting protesting France's remarks
France
criticized U.S. vote on UN rights chief's term extension
Volker Turk
UN high commissioner for human rights whose term extension was opposed by the U.S.
Mike Waltz
U.S. Ambassador to the UN who accused France of supporting lecturing nations
Jerome Bonnafont
French Ambassador to the UN who described Turk as a 'voice of conscience'
Dan Negrea
Senior U.S. official stating the U.S. would continue similar stands
Jeff Bartos
U.S. Ambassador who criticized Turk's reappointment and threatened funding reassessment
Farhan Haq
Deputy UN spokesperson declining to comment on the U.S. walkout
US, France clash at UN over rights chief's term extension

↳ Why This Matters

The incident underscores significant diplomatic tensions between the U.S. and France within the UN framework, particularly concerning human rights issues and international cooperation, potentially impacting future U.S. engagement with UN bodies.

Key facts

  • The U.S. delegation walked out of a UN Security Council meeting.
  • France criticized the U.S. for voting against extending the UN rights chief's term.
  • The U.S. joined Russia and North Korea in voting against the term extension.
  • France's UN Mission stated the U.S. is no longer a beacon of human rights.

The United States delegation walked out of a UN Security Council meeting during remarks by France, protesting comments made by the French UN Mission that criticized the U.S. vote against extending the term of the UN high commissioner for human rights, Volker Turk. The U.S. had joined Russia and North Korea in voting against the extension, prompting France's mission to state that Washington was no longer a beacon of human rights. U.S. Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz accused France of supporting someone who lectured democratic countries while aligning with oppressive regimes. The walkout occurred during an emergency Security Council meeting on the Russia-Ukraine war. A senior U.S. official indicated that such actions would continue until France renounced its rhetoric. The dispute highlights broader tensions between Washington and the UN, with the U.S. having previously cut funding for UN agencies and withdrawn from several UN entities. Ambassador Jeff Bartos had previously criticized Turk's reappointment, warning of consequences and a reassessment of U.S. engagement and funding. Conversely, French Ambassador Jerome Bonnafont defended Turk, calling him a 'voice of conscience' who demonstrated 'rigor and impartiality'. The UN deputy spokesperson declined to comment on the walkout, stating the organization expected member states to respect its decisions.

Frequently asked questions

The U.S. criticized the UN rights chief's reappointment, citing procedural overreach, backroom deals, and misuse of UN posts. Ambassador Jeff Bartos stated there would be consequences and the U.S. would reassess its engagement and funding.

France's UN Mission stated the U.S. was no longer a beacon of human rights. French Ambassador Jerome Bonnafont described the rights chief as a 'voice of conscience' who demonstrated 'rigor and impartiality'.

The U.S. delegation walked out of the meeting while France was speaking, as a protest against France's criticism of the U.S. vote on the human rights chief's term extension.

What Happens Next

01The U.S. will continue to make similar stands until France renounces its rhetoric.

Get the newsletter.

Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

Cadence

How It Developed

The U.S. voted against extending the UN rights chief's term.
France criticized the U.S. vote, stating Washington is 'not anymore' a beacon of human rights.
The U.S. delegation walked out of a UN Security Council meeting during France's remarks.
A senior U.S. official stated similar actions would continue until France renounces its rhetoric.

Sources

T1
US walks out on France at UN meeting to protest ally's criticism of America's human rights recordAP News
T1
US walks out of UN Security Council meeting during France's remarksBBC News
T1
US, France trade barbs in fight over UN rights chief's second termReuters
T1
US walks out on France at UN over human rights criticismSouth China Morning Post

Related Stories

US diplomats walk out of UN meeting after France criticizes human rights record under Trump
28 Jul · 9:51 PM
Iran backs UN rights chief Volker Turk for second term despite US, Israel opposition
28 Jul · 6:36 PM
UN refugee chief hopeful about Washington partnership after reports of possible split with Trump administration
28 Jul · 4:57 PM
USTR: New Trump tariffs unlikely to impact economy
27 Jul · 11:37 PM
Trump officials probe 2 school districts over transgender policies
28 Jul · 2:35 AM