All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
Story archiveAll categories
← All Stories

New Zealand legislation making English an official language ridiculed as ‘pathetic’

Created at 3 Aug · 4:16 AM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

New Zealand parliament passed legislation making English an official language, alongside te reo Māori and New Zealand sign language. The move, part of a coalition deal, has drawn criticism from linguists and legal experts who deem it unnecessary and ideologically driven.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

95%percentage of country speaking English
70-wordlength of legislation

Who's Involved

Tamatha Paul
Green MP who criticized the bill
Casey Costello
MP for New Zealand First defending the bill
Winston Peters
Leader of New Zealand First and Foreign Affairs Minister
Sidney Wong
Linguist and post-doctoral fellow
Dean Knight
Law professor at Victoria University of Wellington

↳ Why This Matters

The legislation highlights ongoing debates about national identity, language policy, and the role of Māori in New Zealand society, with critics arguing it is a politically motivated move that distracts from more pressing issues.

Key facts

  • New Zealand parliament passed legislation making English an official language.
  • English now shares official status with te reo Māori and New Zealand sign language.
  • The bill was part of a coalition agreement between the National and New Zealand First parties.
  • Critics argue the legislation is unnecessary as English is already dominant and not under threat.
  • Ministry of Justice officials recommended against the bill, stating no evidence supported concerns about English usage.
  • New Zealand's parliament has passed legislation granting English official language status, a move that has been met with derision from experts and opposition MPs. The bill, which became law on July 30, gives English the same standing as te reo Māori and New Zealand sign language, despite English being spoken by 95% of the population.

    The legislation was a component of a coalition agreement between the National Party and the populist New Zealand First party, led by Winston Peters, who has previously expressed concerns about the prominence of Māori in public services.

    Ministry of Justice officials had advised against the bill, stating there was no evidence to suggest English was under threat and that official status was typically granted to languages needing protection, unlike English. However, the coalition government and the main opposition Labour Party voted in favor.

    During parliamentary debate, Green MP Tamatha Paul described the bill as a "pathetic waste of the responsibility of this house" and criticized the coalition for perceived oversensitivity to Māori terms like Aotearoa. Conversely, New Zealand First MP Casey Costello defended the law as a practical measure aligning the statute book with existing practice. Labour stated its support was aimed at moving past a "needless culture war."

    Linguist Dr. Sidney Wong commented that English does not require legislative protection due to its widespread use and lack of threat. He suggested that government funding would be better directed towards research on New Zealand English rather than this short piece of legislation. Law professor Dr. Dean Knight echoed these sentiments, calling the act a "pointless exercise" that has no practical or legal impact, as English remains the dominant language.

    Frequently asked questions

    The legislation was part of a coalition deal between the National Party and New Zealand First. Winston Peters, leader of New Zealand First, argued it was necessary due to perceived confusion over the use of Māori in public services.

    Many experts, including linguist Dr. Sidney Wong and law professor Dr. Dean Knight, criticized the bill as unnecessary and pointless, arguing that English is already the dominant language and not under threat.

    New Zealand now has three official languages: te reo Māori, New Zealand sign language, and English.

    What Happens Next

    01The law officially takes effect, granting English the same status as te reo Māori and New Zealand sign language.

    Get the newsletter.

    Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

    Cadence

    How It Developed

    Legislation recognizing English as an official language in New Zealand was passed by parliament.
    The bill grants English the same official status as te reo Māori and New Zealand sign language.
    Ministry of Justice officials advised against the bill, citing no evidence of English being under threat.
    Green MP Tamatha Paul criticized the bill as a 'pathetic waste' and accused the coalition of being 'snowflakes'.
    MP Casey Costello defended the bill as a practical measure aligning the statute book with practice.
    Winston Peters argued the bill was necessary due to perceived confusion over the use of Māori in public services.
    Labour voted in favor to move past a 'needless culture war'.
    Linguist Dr. Sidney Wong stated English does not require protection as it is not under threat.

    Sources

    T1
    New Zealand legislation making English an official language ridiculed as ‘pathetic’The Guardian

    Related Stories

    Farage struck deal for political return months before election, reports say
    2 Aug · 2:51 PM
    Burnham vows 'relentless' action on UK small boat crossings
    2 Aug · 4:06 PM
    Burnham pushes to keep child rapists in prison as release scheme talks near deadline
    2 Aug · 3:41 PM
    Nigel Farage faces political headwinds as Labour gains momentum
    3 Aug · 2:31 AM
    One Nation unveils eight Victorian election candidates including former Liberal and anti-woke film animator
    3 Aug · 1:56 AM