HomeEverythingEducation
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
← All Stories

Israel government defies Supreme Court ruling on media regulator

Created at 5 Jul · 5:32 PM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

Israel's cabinet voted to reject a Supreme Court decision regarding the country's broadcast regulator, raising concerns of a constitutional crisis. This marks the first time Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has openly flouted a court ruling, drawing condemnation from opposition leaders.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

June 17date of court order
October 7, 2023date of Hamas attacks

Who's Involved

Benjamin Netanyahu
Prime Minister of Israel
Shlomo Karhi
Communications Minister
Yariv Levin
Justice Minister and proponent of judicial changes
Yair Lapid
Israeli opposition leader
Naftali Bennett
Former Prime Minister of Israel
Gadi Eisenkot
Leading opposition figure
Second Authority for Television and Radio
Israel's broadcast regulator
Channel 13
Major commercial television network
Channel 14
Right-wing, pro-Netanyahu television channel
Israel government defies Supreme Court ruling on media regulator

↳ Why This Matters

The Israeli government's defiance of a Supreme Court ruling on its media regulator raises serious concerns about the separation of powers and the stability of Israeli democracy. This action could lead to a constitutional crisis and impact the operations and ownership of key media outlets.

Key facts

  • Israel's cabinet voted to defy a Supreme Court ruling concerning the country's broadcast regulator.
  • The government argues the Second Authority for Television and Radio lacks the legal quorum to make decisions.
  • The Supreme Court had ordered the regulator to continue its operations.
  • This is the first time Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has directly challenged a Supreme Court ruling.
  • Opposition leaders and legal experts have expressed concerns about a constitutional crisis and the impact on Israeli democracy.

Israel's cabinet has voted to defy a Supreme Court ruling that mandated the country's broadcast regulator, the Second Authority for Television and Radio, to continue its operations despite lacking the required number of members. The government, led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, argues that the council does not meet the legal threshold to make decisions.

This decision marks a significant escalation in the government's clashes with the judiciary, being the first time it has openly flouted a Supreme Court ruling. Communications Minister Shlomo Karhi and Justice Minister Yariv Levin, a key proponent of judicial reforms, proposed that the government not recognize any council decisions until the membership requirement is met. They stated that the court cannot "trample on the law" and that decisions made under the current circumstances are void.

Opposition leaders have strongly condemned the cabinet's vote. Yair Lapid described it as "the most serious constitutional crisis in Israel's history" and "the destruction of the foundations of our democracy." Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett warned of anarchy, while Gadi Eisenkot stated the government was "raising a hand against Israeli democracy."

Legal experts have voiced concerns about a potential constitutional crisis. The cabinet's decision could also impact the approval of the sale of Channel 13, a critic of Netanyahu, and the classification of Channel 14, which enjoys regulatory benefits as a "small channel." New elections are anticipated in September or October.

Frequently asked questions

The government argues that the Second Authority for Television and Radio does not have the minimum number of members required by law to make decisions, rendering its actions invalid.

This is the first time Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has openly flouted a Supreme Court ruling, raising concerns about a constitutional crisis and the future of Israel's democratic foundations.

The decision could affect the approval of the sale of Channel 13 and the regulatory status of Channel 14. It has also sparked strong condemnation from opposition leaders and legal experts.

What Happens Next

01New elections are expected in September or October.
02The impact on the potential sale of Channel 13 will become clearer.
03The classification of Channel 14 may be re-evaluated.

Get the newsletter.

Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

Cadence

How It Developed

The Second Authority for Television and Radio was ordered by the court to continue operations despite lacking the required number of members.
The Israeli cabinet voted unanimously to reject the Supreme Court's ruling.
Communications Minister Shlomo Karhi and Justice Minister Yariv Levin proposed not recognizing council decisions until membership thresholds are met.
Opposition leader Yair Lapid called the government's action "the most serious constitutional crisis in Israel's history."
Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett warned that not adhering to court rulings leads to anarchy.
Gadi Eisenkot stated the government was "raising a hand against Israeli democracy."
The cabinet's decision could impact the potential sale of Channel 13 and the classification of Channel 14.

Sources

T1
Israel government says it will defy Supreme Court ruling on media regulatorReuters

Related Stories

Ben Gvir Cancels New York Trip Amid Calls for Arrest
5 Jul · 2:15 AM
Trump says Netanyahu knows who is 'the boss'
5 Jul · 2:05 AM
US Supreme Court to Hear Major Cases on Guns, LGBT Rights, Voting
5 Jul · 10:07 AM
Police arrest 14 activists at London protest marking Palestine Action ban
5 Jul · 4:10 PM
Interior Secretary defends white nationalist march as free speech
4 Jul · 8:13 PM